Stolen Ukrainian universities: An invisible russian weapon
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/ppm.23(2-si).2025.11
-
Article InfoVolume 23 2025, Issue #2 (spec. issue), pp. 151-175
- 80 Views
-
8 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
This paper explores the issue of “stolen” Ukrainian universities. Over 1,500 Ukrainian educational and research organizations have been seized by Russia, including 289 higher education institutions such as universities, institutes, academies, colleges, and their branches. These institutions are now exploited to further Russia’s geopolitical agenda through propaganda, territorial annexation justification, and the assimilation of the Ukrainian population in occupied regions. The study examines this using the following examples: the perception of stolen Ukrainian universities as Russian entities by international organizations and academic communities; recognition of stolen Ukrainian intellectual property as Russian, with silent approval or facilitation, such as the registration and confirmation of stolen Ukrainian academic journals by the International ISSN Centre. The paper highlights the use of these stolen institutions’ resources as propaganda tools, their role in ideological manipulation, and their contribution to the assimilation of occupied territories. Recommendations include removing stolen universities from academic affiliations and databases, revoking ISSN registrations for stolen Ukrainian journals, and urging COPE to issue ethical guidelines for preventing collaboration with stolen universities. Additionally, it emphasizes the need for Ukrainian authorities and the academic community to engage proactively with global publishing institutions, database owners, and organizations handling publishing ethics to address these challenges. By bringing attention to this “silent war on knowledge”, the paper underscores the urgency of addressing the misuse of stolen academic institutions by Russia to uphold the integrity of global academia and international law.
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)H56, I20, N30, N40
-
References52
-
Tables2
-
Figures20
-
- Figure 1. Structure of stolen institutions of higher education by type of education organization
- Figure 2. Geographical structure of stolen institutions of higher education
- Figure 3. A screenshot from the ISSN portal for the record 2413-1709
- Figure 4. A screenshot from the ISSN portal for the record 2312-5330
- Figure A1. A screenshot from the ISSN portal for the record 2413-1938 (date of access May 1, 2024)
- Figure A2. A screenshot from the ISSN portal for the record 2413-1938 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure A3. A screenshot from Elsevier for the record 10.1016/j.yebeh.2024.110116 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure A4. A screenshot from Scopus for the record 2-s2.0-85208193276 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure A5. A screenshot from PubMed for the record 39510014 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure A6. A screenshot from ResearchGate for the record 386309749 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure B1. A screenshot from the ISSN portal for the record 2415-8720 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure B2. A screenshot from the official Springer site for the record s10958-024-07493-3 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure B3. A screenshot from the official Scopus site for the record 2-s2.0-85210511743 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure B4. A screenshot from ResearchGate for the record 379710011 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure C1. A screenshot from the ISSN portal for the record 2409-4617 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure C2. A screenshot from the official Springer site for the record S1068162024020183 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure C3. A screenshot from the official Scopus site for the record 57197825789 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure C4. A screenshot from the official Scopus site for the record 2-s2.0-85189918707 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure C5. A screenshot from the ResearchGate site for the record 379707935 (date of access January 1, 2025)
- Figure C6. A screenshot from the ResearchGate site for the profile Victor Dotsenko (date of access January, 1, 2025)
-
- Table 1. All types of educational facilities and education management authorities situated on occupied territories as of January 1, 2025
- Table A1. Stolen Ukrainian universities and research centers used to create the Crimean Federal University
-
- Abalkina, A. (2021). Detecting a network of hijacked journals by its archive. Scientometrics 126, 7123-7148.
- Abalkina, A. (2024). Challenges posed by hijacked journals in Scopus. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 75(4), 395-422.
- Bouchet-Saulnier, F. (1998). The practical guide to humanitarian law. Paris: Doctors Without Borders.
- Bredikhin, A. (2015, January 16). Sistema obrazovanija v DNR i LNR: Ispytanija i razvitie [Education system in the DPR and LPR: Testing and development]. Fund for Support and Protection of the Rights of Compatriots Living Abroad. (In Russian).
- Brennan, J., King, R., & Lebeau, Y. (2004). The role of universities in the transformation of societies: an international research project. London: Centre for Higher Education Research and Information/Association of Commonwealth Universities.
- Carter, D. (2024, March 1). One in five HE institutions damaged or destroyed in war. University World News.
- Chala, N. (2024, January 26). Impact of war on science and academic communities: Vulnerability and responsibility of scientists. Science at Risk.
- Chumachenko, D. (2024, March 27). The silent casualty – How the Russian war is eroding Ukraine’s scientific potential. Wonk HE.
- Chumachenko, D., Bilous, O., Sherengovsky, D., & Zarembo, K. (2022). Russian universities must suffer tougher sanctions. Times Higher Education.
- Council of the European Union. (2023). ERAC Report on the role of Research and Innovation in Ukraine’s Recovery.
- de Rassenfosse, G., Murovana, T., & Uhlbach, W.-H. (2023). The effects of war on Ukrainian research. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 10, Article 856.
- Dodonov, R. (2016). Peremishcheni vyshchi navchalni zaklady – Novyi fenomen v ukrainskii osviti [Relocated higher education institutions are a new phenomenon in Ukrainian education]. In Znannia. Osvita. Osvichenist. (In Ukrainian).
- Donetsk State University. (2024a, December 12). Sotrudniki juridicheskogo fakul’teta okazali pomoshh’ voinam SVO [Members of the Faculty of Law provided assistance to the soldiers of the SVO]. (In Russian).
- Donetsk State University. (2024b, December 7). Jeksperty obsudili istoricheskoe znachenie Russkoj vesny [Experts discussed the historical significance of the Russian Spring]. (In Russian).
- Gerhard, V. G. (1957). The occupation of enemy territory: A commentary on the law and practice of belligerent occupation. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
- Hague Convention (IV). (1907). Respecting the laws and customs of war on land and its annex: Regulations concerning the laws and customs of war on land.
- Haraschenko, N., Pravdyva, O., Skorokhod, O., Vasylieva, N., Pareniuk, O., Horokhovatska, M., Omelianenko, V., & Tsyplitska, O. (2024). Transforming the research and innovation system for post-war recovery (White Paper 2024). Science at Risk.
- Harashchenko, N., Hladchenko, L., Korytnikova, N., Lutsenko, A., Moskotina, R., & Pravdyva, O. (2022). Ukrainian researchers in times of war. Results of survey. UAScience. Reload.
- Human Rights Watch (HRW). (2024, June 20). Ukraine: Forced Russified education under occupation.
- Kubijovyč, V., Miller, M., Ohloblyn, O., Stebelsky, I., & Zhukovsky, A. (2022). Crimea. In Internet Encyclopedia of Ukraine.
- Luhansk State Medical University named after St. Luke. (2024a, December 18). Akcija Volontjorskogo otrjada “Dobrodetel” [Action of the Volunteer Unit “Virtue”]. (In Russian).
- Luhansk State Medical University named after St. Luke. (2024b, December 17). Patrioticheskaja akcija “Pozdrav geroja s Novym godom” [Patriotic action “Congratulate a hero on the New Year”]. (In Russian).
- Luhansk State Medical University named after St. Luke. (2024c, February 21). “Svoih ne brosaem!” [“We Don’t Abandon Our People”]. (In Russian).
- Lutsenko, A., Harashchenko, N., Hladchenko, L., Korytnikova, N., Moskotina, R., & Pravdyva, O. (2023). The results of the survey on the needs of Ukrainian scientists (First wave report) (Research Paper No. 23-03). Max Planck Institute for Innovation & Competition.
- Lychko, T., Vorobyova, A., Sulialina, M., Shapoval, O., & Okhredko, O. (2024). The “University sessions” program as the instrument for the indoctrination and destruction of the Ukrainian identity of children and youth from the temporarily occupied territories (Analytical report) (78 p.). Kyiv: CCE “Almenda”.
- Lyman, I., & Moskovko, M. (2024). Systematising the practises and recommendations of Ukrainian institutions with damaged and destroyed research infrastructure: Methods of calculations of losses, recovery needs, fundrasing, and feedback on data collection (White Paper). Science at Risk.
- Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine (MESI). (2023, February). Overview of the current state of education and science in Ukraine under russian aggression.
- Moscow State University. (2022a, June 4). Pervyj forum obrazovatelnyh organizacij Rossii i Donbassa [First forum of educational organizations of Russia and Donbass]. (In Russian).
- Moscow State University. (2022b, August 9). “Prishla horoshaja smena”. V Moskve proshla onlajn-press-konferencija rektora MGU im. M.V. Lomonosova akademika Viktora Sadovnichego [“A good change has come.” Lomonosov Moscow State University’s Rector, Academician Viktor Sadovnichy held an online press conference in Moscow]. (In Russian).
- Moscow State University. (2023, August 30). MGU prinjal v jetom godu 115 abiturientov-uchastnikov SVO I ih detej [MSU accepted 115 SWO applicants and their children this year]. (In Russian).
- Murphy, C. (1999). Crimes of war: What the public should know. In R. Gutman & D. Rieff (Eds.), Crimes of war: What the public should know (p. 264). New York/London: W.W. Norton & Co.
- Nosok, V. (2024, March 11). “The main thing is not the walls, the main thing is the people” – Displaced universities in a war zone. Wonk HE.
- Orzhel, O., Trofymenko, M., Porkuian, O., Drach, I., Halhash, R., & Stoyka, A. (2023). Displaced universities in Ukraine: Challenges and optimal development models. European Journal of Education, 58(4), 629-646.
- Plastun, A. (2025). Supplementary information to “Stolen Ukrainian Universities: An invisible russian weapon”. Zenodo.
- Plastun, A., & Makarenko, I. (2024). International academic collaboration with Russian war supporters (16 p.). Sumy State University.
- Plastun, O., Makarenko, I., & Berger-Hrynova, T. (2024a). Science vs Propaganda: The case of Russia (15 p.). Sumy State University: CNRS.
- Plastun, O., Makarenko, I., & Berger-Hrynova, T. (2024b). Potemkin village of Russian science: The case of Editorial Boards (11 p.). Sumy State University: CNRS.
- RBC. (2023, August 7). V Moskve pokazali novye uchebniki po istorii s operaciej na Ukraine [Moscow showed new history textbooks with operation in Ukraine]. (In Russian).
- Redzik, A. (2004). Polish universities during the Second World War.
- Roache, M. (2018, August 10). The forgotten story behind Crimea’s only displaced university. Atlantic Council.
- Robinson, J. (1954). Transfer of property in enemy occupied territory. American Journal of International Law, 39(2), 216-230.
- Science at Risk. (2024). Academia in Ukraine in times of war: Understanding the status quo, challenges, and support needs (Science at Risk Monitoring Report).
- Scopus. (2024). Russian Academy of Sciences.
- Suchikova, Y. (2023). Invisible lives: Occupied cities as a blind spot in geopolitical research. Geopolitics under Globalization, 5(1), 35-45.
- The Crimean Federal University named after V.I. Vernadsky. (2024a, December 18). V Tavricheskom kolledzhe Krymskogo federal’nogo universiteta imeni V.I.Vernadskogo prohodit sbor novogodnih podarkov dlja bojcov special’noj voennoj operacii [The Tavricheskiy College of the Crimean Federal University named after V.I. Vernadsky is collecting New Year gifts for the soldiers of the special military operation]. (In Russian).
- The Crimean Federal University named after V.I. Vernadsky. (2024c, December 6). V Akademii stroitel’stva i arhitektury Krymskogo federal’nogo universiteta sostojalas’ lekcija, posvjashhennaja gerojam special’noj voennoj operacii [The Academy of Construction and Architecture of the Crimean Federal University hosted a lecture dedicated to the heroes of the special military operation]. (In Russian).
- The Crimean Federal University named after V.I. Vernadsky. (2024b, December 12). Na baze Medicinskogo instituta Krymskogo federal’nogo universiteta sostojalsja master-klass po takticheskoj medicine [A master class on tactical medicine was held at the Medical Institute of the Crimean Federal University]. (In Russian).
- The Lebedev Physical Institute. (2023). Itogi pervoj Zimnej shkoly po finansovoj bezopasnosti v “Siriuse” [Results of the first Winter School on Financial Security at “Sirius”]. (In Russian).
- UNESCO. (1945). Education under enemy occupation in Belgium, China, Czechoslovakia, France, Greece, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Norway, Poland (Bulletin No. 3).
- UNESCO. (2024). Analysis of war damage to the Ukrainian science sector and its consequences.
- Vlasenko, M., & Zelmanov, E. (2023). Voices from the bombed universities of Ukraine. American Mathematical Society.
- Zelenetska, V. (2024, December 26). The occupiers have created a program for Ukrainian children to study in russia.