Assessing ISO 14001:2015 compliance in Iraqi healthcare: A comparative study of environmental management in public and private hospitals

  • 66 Views
  • 15 Downloads

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

The implementation of environmental management systems is increasingly recognized as essential for advancing sustainability in healthcare, particularly in resource-constrained contexts such as Iraq. This study evaluates the compliance of Iraqi public and private hospitals with ISO 14001:2015 standards, revealing significant discrepancies between the two sectors. Utilizing a quantitative descriptive approach, data were collected through field surveys, structured interviews, and document analysis to assess environmental management systems practices. Private hospitals demonstrated a compliance rate of 75%, while public hospitals achieved a compliance rate of only 50%. Key deficiencies in public hospitals were identified in operation (78% gap) and improvement (73% gap), indicating systemic weaknesses. Although private hospitals performed better, they still exhibited notable gaps, particularly in leadership and performance evaluation, both at 29%. Challenges common to both sectors included insufficient resource allocation, limited environmental awareness, and inadequate leadership involvement. These findings underscore the urgent need for targeted interventions to address barriers to adoption of environmental management systems. Strategies such as fostering stronger leadership commitment, optimizing resource allocation, incorporating advanced environmental technologies, and implementing ongoing staff training are recommended to bridge the compliance gap. This study provides critical insights into enhancing environmental performance and promoting sustainable healthcare practices in Iraq. Furthermore, it serves as a reference for addressing similar challenges in developing countries, emphasizing the importance of aligning healthcare operations with international environmental management standards.

Acknowledgment
The authors wish to convey their sincere appreciation to the two selected hospitals for their cooperation and willingness to participate in this study. The provision of necessary documentation and the allocation of time by these institutions have been invaluable in facilitating the completion of the research.

view full abstract hide full abstract
    • Figure 1. Size of the final gap in the research sample (Hospitals A and B)
    • Table 1. Example of how questions and answer options are presented in the questionnaire
    • Table 2. The size of the gap in Section 4: Context of the organization
    • Table 3. The size of the gap in Section 5: Leadership
    • Table 4. The size of the gap in Section 6: Planning
    • Table 5. The size of the gap in Section 7: Support
    • Table 6. The size of the gap in Section 8: Operation
    • Table 7. The size of the gap in Section 9: Performance evaluation
    • Table 8. The size of the gap in Section 10: Improvement
    • Table A1. Overview of the ISO 14001:2015 requirements (Sections and sub-sections)
    • Conceptualization
      Huda Jabbar, Ghada Ibrahim, Alissar Yassin Haddad
    • Data curation
      Huda Jabbar, Ghada Ibrahim
    • Formal Analysis
      Huda Jabbar, Ghada Ibrahim, Soumaya Kaakour
    • Funding acquisition
      Huda Jabbar, Ghada Ibrahim, Nadine Al-Khatib, Soumaya Kaakour
    • Investigation
      Huda Jabbar
    • Methodology
      Huda Jabbar, Ghada Ibrahim, Nadine Al-Khatib
    • Resources
      Huda Jabbar, Ghada Ibrahim, Nadine Al-Khatib, Soumaya Kaakour
    • Software
      Huda Jabbar, Alissar Yassin Haddad
    • Visualization
      Huda Jabbar, Ghada Ibrahim, Nadine Al-Khatib, Alissar Yassin Haddad
    • Writing – original draft
      Huda Jabbar, Ghada Ibrahim, Alissar Yassin Haddad
    • Project administration
      Ghada Ibrahim, Alissar Yassin Haddad
    • Supervision
      Ghada Ibrahim, Alissar Yassin Haddad
    • Validation
      Ghada Ibrahim, Nadine Al-Khatib, Soumaya Kaakour
    • Writing – review & editing
      Ghada Ibrahim, Nadine Al-Khatib, Soumaya Kaakour