The impact of cookie regime change on the effectiveness of automatic retargeting in advertising
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/im.19(2).2023.09
-
Article InfoVolume 19 2023, Issue #2, pp. 101-114
- Cited by
- 518 Views
-
238 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
The constantly evolving legislation concerning the usage of cookies raises many concerns about the effectiveness of targeted online advertisements. Retargeting represents an advanced targeting strategy requiring detailed user data and thus may be potentially highly sensitive to cookie restrictions. The retargeting effectiveness is tested in terms of type (standard, dynamic), advertising platform (Meta Ads, Google Ads), and the ad performance development in time. The data were collected through a Czech home goods online retailer. This paper tests the effectiveness of 432 retargeting ads collected during the opt-out cookie regime by comparing them with 432 retargeting ads collected after the transition to the opt-in cookie regime. The study created 216 ads on Google and 216 ads on Facebook. The entire experiment took one month to be implemented in 2021 and repeated in precisely the same manner in 2022. After this period, data were processed with SPSS Statistics. Both Facebook and Google (Conversion Lift) provide A/B testing tools. The results suggest that standard retargeting ads are more effective in utilitarian browsing. In contrast, dynamic retargeting is more successful in reaching users in the hedonic environment of social networks. Moreover, the performance of retargeting ads evolves in the different stages along the customer journey. There are differences in the total number of tracked users in terms of the transition from the opt-out to the opt-in cookie regime. However, the performance of programmatic advertising appears moderately affected.
Acknowledgment
This work is supported by the Technology Agency of the Czech Republic under the Program of Applied Research ZETA through the Grant TJ02000206 – Developing the skills necessary for the digital business transformation.
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)M37, M38, M39
-
References50
-
Tables7
-
Figures4
-
- Figure 1. Standard retargeting mechanism in advertising
- Figure 2. Dynamic retargeting mechanism in advertising
- Figure 3. The principle of A/B testing with the Conversion Lift and Facebook
- Figure 4. Retargeting performance development over time
-
- Table 1. Parameters and numbers of the test campaigns
- Table 2. Summary statistics for the 2021 data set
- Table 3. Summary statistics for the 2022 data set
- Table 4. Average retargeting performance per week
- Table 5. Paired samples test: Standard and dynamic
- Table 6. Paired samples test: Meta 2021 and 2022
- Table 7. Paired samples test: Google 2021 and 2022
-
- Berman, R. (2018). Beyond the last touch: Attribution in online advertising. Marketing Science, 37(5), 771-792.
- Bleier, A., & Eisenbeiss, M. (2015). The importance of trust for personalized online advertising. Journal of Retailing, 91(3), 390-409.
- Blomster, M., & Koivumäki, T. (2022). Exploring the resources, competencies, and capabilities needed for successful machine learning projects in digital marketing. Information Systems and e-Business Management, 20(1), 123-169.
- Boerman, S., Kruikemeier, S., & Zuiderveen Borgesius, F. (2017). Online behavioral advertising: A literature review and research agenda. Journal of Advertising, 46(3), 363-376.
- Bucklin, R., Lehmann, D., & Little, J. (1998). From decision support to decision automation: A 2020 vision. Marketing Letters, 9(3), 235-246.
- Choi, W. J., & Sayedi, A. (2019). Learning in online advertising. Marketing Science, 38(4), 584-608.
- Cooper, D., Yalcin, T., Nistor, C., Macrini, M., & Pehlivan, E. (2023). Privacy considerations for online advertising: A stakeholder’s perspective to programmatic advertising. Journal of Consumer Marketing, 40(2), 235-247.
- De Tuna, T., Akbas, E., Aksoy, A., Canbaz, M., Karabiyik, U., Gonen, B., & Aygun, R. (2016). User characterization for online social networks. Social Network Analysis and Mining, 6(1), 104.
- European Parliament & Council of the European Union. (2002). Directive 2002/58/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 July 2002 concerning the processing of personal data and the protection of privacy in the electronic communications sector (Directive on privacy and electronic communications).
- European Parliament & Council of the European Union. (2009). Corrigendum to Directive 2009/136/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 November 2009 amending Directive 2002/22/EC on universal service and users’ rights relating to electronic communications networks and services, Directive 2002/58/EC concerning the processing of personal data and the protection of privacy in the electronic communications sector and Regulation (EC) No 2006/2004 on cooperation between national authorities responsible for the enforcement of consumer protection laws (OJ L 337, 18.12.2009).
- Goeldner, C. (1962). Automation in marketing. Journal of Marketing, 26(1), 53-56.
- Google. (n.d.a). How Google uses cookies.
- Google. (n.d.b). Google Analytics Cookie Usage on Websites.
- Google. (n.d.c). Standard Google Ads remarketing – Tag Manager Help.
- Google. (n.d.d). Standard Google Ads remarketing.
- Google. (n.d.e). Google Ads dynamic remarketing – Tag Manager Help.
- Google. (n.d.f). About bid strategy statuses – Google Ads Help.
- Hoffmanová, M., & Bešťáková, L. (2022, January 5). Czech Republic: Changes to the Electronic Communications Act new rules relating to cookies and telemarketing effective as of 1 January 2022. Insightplus.bakermckenzie.com.
- Indrawati, I., Ramantoko, G., Widarmanti, T., Aziz, I., & Khan, F. (2022). Utilitarian, hedonic, and self-esteem motives in online shopping. Spanish Journal of Marketing – ESIC, 26(2), 231-246.
- Jiang, Z., Chan, T., Che, H., & Wang, Y. (2021). Consumer search and purchase: An empirical investigation of retargeting based on consumer online behaviors. Marketing Science, 40(2), 219-240.
- Jiang, Z., Dan, W., & Jie, L. (2020). Distinct role of targeting precision of Internet-based targeted advertising in duopolistic e- business firms’ heterogeneous consumers market. Electronic Commerce Research, 20(2), 453-474.
- Johnson, G. A., Shriver, S. K., & Du, S. (2020). Consumer privacy choice in online advertising: Who opts out and at what cost to industry? Marketing Science, 39(1), 33-51.
- Kim, M., & Ohk, K. (2017). The bright side and dark side of retargeting advertising. International Information Institute, 20(5A), 3073-3081.
- King, N., & Jessen, P. (2010). Profiling the mobile customer – Is industry self-regulation adequate to protect consumer privacy when behavioural advertisers target mobile phones? – Part II. Computer Law & Security Review, 26(6), 595-612.
- Lambrecht, A., & Tucker, C. (2013). When does retargeting work? Information specificity in online advertising. Journal of Marketing Research, 50(5), 561-576.
- Markou, C. (2016). Behavioural advertising and the new ‘EU Cookie Law’ as a victim of business resistance and a lack of official determination. In S. Gutwirth, R. Leenes, & P. De Hert (Eds.), Data protection on the move (pp. 213-247). Dordrecht: Springer.
- Masood, R., Berkovsky, S., & Kaafar, M. A. (2022). Tracking and personalization. In B. P. Knijnenburg, X. Page, P. Wisniewski, H. R. Lipford, N. Proferes, & J. Romano (Eds.), Modern Socio-technical perspectives on privacy (pp. 171-202). Cham: Springer.
- Meta. (n.d.a). Conversion Tracking.
- Meta. (n.d.b). About Standard and Custom Website Events.
- Meta. (n.d.c). Create and Expand a Retargeting Campaign.
- Meta. (n.d.d). Guide to the learning phase.
- Ministry of Industry and Trade of the Czech Republic. (2005). Act No. 127/2005 Coll. on Electronic Communications and on Amendment to Certain Related Acts (Electronic Communications Act).
- Ohiomah, A., Andreev, P., Benyoucef, M., & Hood, D. (2019). The role of lead management systems in inside sales performance. Journal of Business Research, 102, 163-177.
- Sahni, N., Narayanan, S., & Kalyanam, K. (2019). An experimental investigation of the effects of retargeted advertising: The role of frequency and timing. Journal of Marketing Research, 56(3), 401-418.
- Sakamoto, T., & Matsunaga, M. (2019). After GDPR, still tracking or not? Understanding opt-out states for online behavioral advertising. 2019 IEEE Security And Privacy Workshops (SPW) (pp. 92-99). San Francisco, CA, USA.
- Saleh, K. (n.d.). Ad Retargeting in Numbers – Statistics and Trends. Invesp.
- Semerádová, T., & Weinlich, P. (2019). Computer estimation of customer similarity with Facebook lookalikes: Advantages and disadvantages of hyper-targeting. In IEEE Access, 7 (pp. 153365-153377).
- Semerádová, T., & Weinlich, P. (2020a). Readiness of small and medium enterprises for marketing automation. ACC Journal, 26(2), 54-68.
- Semerádová, T., & Weinlich, P. (2020b). Reaching your customers using Facebook and Google dynamic ads. In T. Semerádová & P. Weinlich (Eds.), Impacts of online advertising on business performance (pp. 177-199). IGI Global.
- Steinbach, J., Krisch, M., & Harguth, H. (2015). Eine neue Philosophie im Marketing: Helpvertising statt Advertising. In Helpvertising essentials (pp. 9-22). Wiesbaden: Springer Gabler. (In German).
- Strong, E. (1925). The psychology of selling and advertising. McGraw-Hill.
- Su, K., Huang, P., Chen, P., & Li, Y. (2016). The impact of formats and interactive modes on the effectiveness of mobile advertisements. Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing, 7(6), 817-827.
- Thomas, J. (2018). Programming, filtering, adblocking: Advertising and media automation. Media International Australia, 166(1), 34-43.
- Todri, V. (2022). Frontiers: The impact of ad-blockers on online consumer behavior. Marketing Science, 41(1), 7-18.
- Tucker, C. (2014). Social networks, personalized advertising, and privacy controls. Journal of Marketing Research, 51(5), 546-562.
- Varnali, K. (2021). Online behavioral advertising: An integrative review. Journal of Marketing Communications, 27(1), 93-114.
- Vecchione, A., Brown, D., Allen, E., & Baschnagel, A. (2016). Tracking user behavior with Google Analytics Events on an Academic Library Web Site. Journal of Web Librarianship, 10(3), 161-175.
- Villas-Boas, J. M., & Yao, Y. J. (2021). A dynamic model of optimal retargeting. Marketing Science, 40(3), 428-458.
- White, T., Zahay, D., Thorbjørnsen, H., & Shavitt, S. (2008). Getting too personal: Reactance to highly personalized email solicitations. Marketing Letters, 19(1), 39-50.
- Zhou, L. (2020). Product advertising recommendation in e-commerce based on deep learning and distributed expression. Electronic Commerce Research, 20(2), 321-342.