GovTech maturity and digital payment adoption in transition economies: Delayed associations and divergent deployment models
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/bbs.21(3).2026.16
-
Article InfoVolume 21 2026, Issue #3, pp. 241–260
- 15 Views
-
2 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Type of the article: Research Article
Abstract
Digital government platforms are expected to accelerate the shift to cashless payments, and banks stand between the two: they hold the accounts that digital credentials open and process the government-to-person and person-to-government flows that digital services generate. Cross-country evidence for transition economies remains scarce and largely contemporaneous. The study aims to determine whether digital government maturity is associated with the uptake of cashless payment instruments contemporaneously or with a delay, and whether the deployment model shapes that association beyond aggregate index scores. Wave panels combining the Global Findex database (2011–2024) with the UN E-Government Development Index for eleven transition economies were estimated using pooled, fixed-effects, between-country, lagged, and first-difference specifications, supplemented by an exploratory annual panel of ATM density and a structured comparison of three deployment models. A strong cross-country association between GovTech maturity and both digital payment adoption (0.551, p < 0.001) and account ownership (0.730, p < 0.001) did not survive within-country identification: fixed-effects coefficients turned negative and insignificant, so H1-H3 are not supported. With a four-to-five-year lag, the Online Service Index entered positively and significantly in the baseline specification (0.290, p < 0.05); as significance is not retained with controls, the evidence is consistent with a delayed association rather than establishing it. Adoption expanded under all three deployment models, from 47% to 85% in Kazakhstan, 48% to 83% in Ukraine, and 12% to 61% in Armenia; what distinguished the cases was the interface between the state and private bank ecosystems, which aggregate indices do not capture.
Acknowledgment
Liudmyla Zakharkina’s contribution to this article was made within the framework of the research project “GovTech for Ukraine: A Digital, Secure, Transparent, and Equitable State in Times of War and Post-War Reconstruction” (registration number: 0126U000544), funded by the Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine.
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)E42, G21, O33, H11, O57
-
References74
-
Tables6
-
Figures2
-
- Figure 1. Digital payment adoption in the focal countries against the regional background, 2014–2024
- Figure 2. GovTech maturity (Online Service Index) in the focal countries against the regional background, 2010–2024
-
- Table 1. Descriptive statistics
- Table 2. GovTech maturity and digital payment adoption (H1)
- Table 3. GovTech maturity and account ownership (H2)
- Table 4. GovTech maturity and payment infrastructure: levels and first differences (H3)
- Table 5. Lagged and first-difference specifications (H4)
- Table A1. Sample composition
-
- Anguelov, K., & Stoyanova, T. (2025). Assessment of factors influencing market leadership and innovation of FinTech companies in the digital economy. Economics Ecology Socium, 9(3), 93-109.
- Azmeh, C., & Al-Raeei, M. (2024). Exploring the dual relationship between fintech and financial inclusion in developing countries and their impact on economic growth: Supplement or substitute? PLOS ONE, 19(12), e0315174.
- Bachas, P., Gertler, P., Higgins, S., & Seira, E. (2021). How debit cards enable the poor to save more. The Journal of Finance, 76(4), 1913-1957.
- Bezverkhyi, K., Parasii-Verhunenko, I., Yurchenko, O., Kazak, O., Zhytar, M., & Poddubna, N. (2024). Conceptual basis of anti-corruption audit. Financial and Credit Activity: Problems of Theory and Practice, 6(59), 77-89.
- Bozhenko, V., Boyko, A., Vondráček, M., & Karácsony, P. (2024). Shadow economy and financial stability from the perspective of finance digitalization. Journal of International Studies, 17(2), 191-205.
- Burrell, D. N., Wansi, T., Morin, S. L., Rahim, E., Tessema, D. B., Alemu, B. A., Harris, N., & Conley, L. (2025). Harnessing behavioral economics, green promotions, and financial incentives as catalysts for sustainable practices. Green Transition and Sustainable Development, 1(1), 1-16.
- Chehayeb, R. J., & Taher, H. (2024). The relationship between financial inclusion and economic growth: Empirical study from MENA countries. Global Business & Finance Review, 29(7), 153-167.
- Demirgüç-Kunt, A., Klapper, L., Singer, D., & Ansar, S. (2022). The Global Findex Database 2021: Financial inclusion, digital payments, and resilience in the age of COVID-19. World Bank.
- Dener, C., Nii-Aponsah, H., Ghunney, L. E., & Johns, K. D. (2021). GovTech Maturity Index: The state of public sector digital transformation. World Bank.
- Deruma, S. (2025). Cyber resilience key metrics in small and medium-sized enterprises. Economics Ecology Socium, 9(1), 15-23.
- Electronic Government of the Republic of Kazakhstan. (2026, March 19). Digitalization of Kazakhstan: eGov.kz celebrates 20th anniversary.
- European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD). (2024). Transition report 2024-25: Navigating industrial policy.
- Government of Armenia. (2021). Decision No. 183-L of February 11, 2021 on approving the Digitalization Strategy of Armenia for 2021–2025.
- Hayes, R. D., & Burrell, D. N. (2026). Reasonable oversight of the practical, legal, and ethical boundaries impacting human factors trust in automated decision-making. Public Governance, Regulation and Law, 2(1), 33-50.
- Hedau, A. (2025). Socio-economic challenges of digital banking adoption: The impact of perceived usefulness, ease of use, and self-efficacy. SocioEconomic Challenges, 9(3), 133-146.
- Hrytsenko, L., Sheliemina, N., & Latysh, D. (2026). Digital government and health system performance: Does digitalization improve the effectiveness of health expenditure? Health Economics and Management Review, 7(1), 21-40.
- Huseynov, A., Balsalobre-Lorente, D., Hamidova, L., & Samedova, E. (2025). Challenges and opportunities of digital economy development: Case of Azerbaijan. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 23(2), 265-276.
- International Monetary Fund (IMF). (2026a). Financial Access Survey (Version 5.0.0) [Data set].
- International Monetary Fund (IMF). (2026b). Republic of Kazakhstan: Technical assistance report - Next steps and considerations for the Digital Tenge (Technical Assistance Report No. 2026/002).
- International Telecommunication Union (ITU). (2021). Digital skills development - Ukraine - Good practice case study.
- Kadri, N. (2025). Factors influencing customers’ adoption of electronic banking services in commercial banks. Financial Markets, Institutions and Risks, 9(1), 140-161.
- Keser, I., & Mudrić, M. M. (2026). The role of artificial intelligence in digital sustainability and governance systems. Economics Ecology Socium, 10(2), 81-93.
- Kirichok, O., Orlovska, Y., Zhanseitova, G., Oriekhova, A., Babaiev, D., Havrylenko, O., & Vasylieva, T. (2025). Bridging digital innovation and energy justice: The role of artificial intelligence in advancing energy equity. Environmental Economics, 16(4), 166-181.
- Klapper, L., Singer, D., Starita, L., & Norris, A. (2025). The Global Findex Database 2025: Connectivity and financial inclusion in the digital economy. World Bank.
- Koparan, A. (2025). Central Bank Digital Currencies: A review of global trends in adoption, financial inclusion, and the role of country characteristics. Investment Management and Financial Innovations, 22(1), 107-121.
- Kostiushko, I., Juhászová, Z., & Dyvynska, Y. (2025). Mobile social smart technologies to optimise customer support services. Knowledge Economy and Lifelong Learning, 1(1), 66-82.
- Kuzior, A., Pakhnenko, O., Tiutiunyk, I., & Lyeonov, S. (2023a). E-governance in smart cities: Global trends and key enablers. Smart Cities, 6(4), 1663-1689.
- Kuzior, A., Zakharkina, L., Kubaščikova, Z., Chentsov, V., & Lyeonov, S. (2023b). Insurance market transparency research trends: Bibliometric analysis. Insurance Markets and Companies, 14(1), 136-152.
- Kyzenko, O., Sitnicki, M. W., Zahorodnia, K., Hrebeshkova, O., & Verba, V. (2026). Ethical leadership and institutional convergence in European management consulting: A cluster-based comparative analysis. Business Ethics and Leadership, 10(1), 345-366.
- Lajka, N., Pavicevic, D., Martic, V., Crvenica, D., & Abramovic, N. (2025). Digitalisation and application of artificial intelligence in public administration. Transformations in Business & Economics, 24(3), 46-72.
- Laskienė, D., Šiukščiūtė, R., Gižienė, V., & Lyeonov, S. (2026). Financial inclusion and social outcomes in the European Union: Evidence from time-series analysis. Investment Management and Financial Innovations, 23(1), 360-373.
- Litovtseva, V., Krawczyk, D., Kuzior, A., Brychko, M., & Vasylieva, T. (2022). Marketing research in the context of trust in the public sector: A case of the digital environment. Innovative Marketing, 18(4), 133-147.
- Malaquias, R. F., & Hwang, Y. (2025). Mobile devices and mobile internet data services: Implications for mobile banking. Human Technology, 21(1), 161-175.
- Mangudhla, T., Dodoo, R. N. A., Boadi, E. B., Mbona, R. M., & Donkor, M. (2025). Financial literacy and financial well-being of rural farmers: Does financial inclusion matter? Economics and Sociology, 18(3), 26-42.
- Marozva, G., Makoni, P. L., & Golpet, M. K. (2026). Addressing socioeconomic challenges in Sub-Saharan Africa: Insights from the financial inclusion, institutional quality, and economic growth nexus. SocioEconomic Challenges, 10(1), 140-156.
- Ministry of Digital Transformation of Ukraine. (2020, February 2). Reliz mobilnoho zastosunku Diia [Release of the Diia mobile application].
- Muralidharan, K., Niehaus, P., & Sukhtankar, S. (2016). Building state capacity: Evidence from biometric smartcards in India. American Economic Review, 106(10), 2895-2929.
- Mustafa, J. A. (2025). Assessing the role of Fintech, technological infrastructure, and macroeconomic stability on per capita spending as a pathway to economic growth in Jordan. Investment Management and Financial Innovations, 22(4), 43-56.
- Nguyen, D. T. N. (2025). Impact of e-government development, economic growth and government management efficiency on financial performance of commercial banks in ASEAN countries. Asian Journal of Economics and Banking, 9(3), 395-417.
- Ntuli, F., Ntshangase, B. A., & Msosa, S. K. (2025). Innovative financial management reforms: A catalyst of good governance in the South African public sector. Financial Markets, Institutions and Risks, 9(4), 16-29.
- Ozili, P. K. (2018). Impact of digital finance on financial inclusion and stability. Borsa Istanbul Review, 18(4), 329-340.
- Pietrucha, J., & Maciejewski, G. (2025). Precautionary cash holding by consumers making electronic payments and risk-taking behavior. Equilibrium. Quarterly Journal of Economics and Economic Policy, 19(4), 1273-1303.
- Polishchuk, Y., Valko, Y., Shuplat, O., & Vasylyshen, Y. (2025). Global support at the click of a button: How digital remittances help Ukraine during crises. Geopolitics under Globalization, 5(1), 57-67.
- Poorna Chandran, K. R., & Ittimani Tholath, D. (2025). Digital insurance acceptance among older adults in the context of AI. Insurance Markets and Companies, 16(1), 131-145.
- President of Ukraine. (2021, August 24). Prezydent Ukrainy pidpysav zakon, yakyi pryrivniuie e-pasporty u Dii do zvychainykh [The President of Ukraine signed a law that equalizes e-passports from Diya to the highest]. (In Ukrainian).
- Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia. (2020, July 20). Digitalization is a revolutionary process: We should work to develop both content and the technical aspects.
- Rysin, V., Prokopenko, O., Muravskyi, O., Pechenko, R., Holiachuk, N., & Zinchenko, A. (2023). Personalization of banking products (services) using digitalization technologies. WSEAS Transactions on Business and Economics, 20, 2528-2539.
- Saher, L., Vakulenko, I., & Oleksich, Z. (2025). What makes growth inclusive? Cluster-based insights for EU member states. Business Ethics and Leadership, 9(3), 275-289.
- Samarkhanov, A., Junusbekova, G., Kenzhin, Z., & Yesmagambetov, D. (2025). The impact of socio-economic and political factors on the development of e-government in developed and developing countries. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 23(4), 554-565.
- Sartamorn, S., Oe, H., & Yamaoka, Y. (2025). Financial stratification and digital transformation under market disruption: Evidence from Thai SMEs. Financial Markets, Institutions and Risks, 9(3), 49-63.
- Sethy, S. K. (2024). Measuring financial inclusion and its purpose: A cross-country impact assessment. Asian Economics Letters, 5(3).
- Shafitranata, Alvia, L., & Azizah, R. (2026). ESG implementation and its effect on financial performance: Focusing on sustainable financial strategies of green companies in Indonesia. Environmental Economics, 17(1), 12-24.
- Shygun, M., & Bezverkhyi, K. (2026). Sustainability reporting as a tool for corporate social responsibility. European Journal of Sustainable Development Research, 10(1), Article em0337.
- Shygun, M., Bezverkhyi, K., Pylypenko, O., Yurchenko, O., & Poddubna, N. (2023). Presenting financial information in digital formats as a base for analysis and audit of business activities of enterprises. Financial and Credit Activity: Problems of Theory and Practice, 6(53), 233-246.
- Suhanyi, L., Gavura, S., & Suhanyiova, A. (2024). E-government and the sustainable public administration: Digital interaction with public authorities in the regions of the EU. Transformations in Business & Economics, 23(1), 106-126.
- Suominen, K. (2024). Building digital public infrastructure: Lessons learned from Kazakhstan. Center for Strategic and International Studies.
- Suri, T., & Jack, W. (2016). The long-run poverty and gender impacts of mobile money. Science, 354(6317), 1288-1292.
- Tarasenko, I., Saienko, V., Kirizleyeva, A., Vozniakovska, K., Harashchenko, L., & Bodnar, O. (2022). Comparative characteristics of the banking sector in Eastern Europe. International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security, 22(1), 639-649.
- Thapaliya, P. R., & Dongol, P. (2026). Factors influencing the use of digital payment services and customer satisfaction in banking sector: An implication for technological innovation. Innovative Marketing, 22(1), 55-64.
- Topazly, R., Stadniichuk, R., Liubokhynets, L., Shuprudko, N., Zhosan, H., & Plietnov, M. (2026). Institutional trust and governance effectiveness as mediators in transforming digital maturity into post-war infrastructure recovery. Business Ethics and Leadership, 10(1), 188-206.
- Tsymbal, L., & Demediuk, A. (2025). Economic security of Ukraine under war: A foreign trade perspective. Safety and Security Advances, 1(1), 63-78.
- Ugulava, G. (2026). Two faces of decline in public governance: Accountability erosion and rent-seeking. Public Governance, Regulation and Law, 2(1), 20-32.
- United Nations (UN). (2024). E-Government Development Index [Data set]. UN e-Government Knowledgebase.
- Vakhovych, I., Satyvaldieva, B., Dooranov, A., Slynko, M., Marchenko, O., & Salivonchyk, I. (2021). Smart specialization of the region as a tool for modernizing innovative development. Estudios de Economía Aplicada, 39(5).
- Vasconcelos, J. R., Dener, C., Nii-Aponsah, H., Blanco, C. V., Immonen, A. J., Nordlund, P., Siregar, F., & Song, Y. (2025). GovTech Maturity Index 2025: Tracking public sector digital transformation worldwide. World Bank.
- Waliszewski, K., Cichowicz, E., Gębski, Ł., Kliber, F., Kubiczek, J., Niedziółka, P., Solarz, M., & Warchlewska, A. (2024). Digital loans and buy now pay later from LendTech versus bank loans in the era of ‘black swans’: Complementarity in the area of consumer financing. Equilibrium. Quarterly Journal of Economics and Economic Policy, 19(1), 241-278.
- Wieczorek, A., & Postrzednik-Lotko, K. (2025). Machine learning algorithms on social media: Privacy risks, user awareness and security implications. Safety and Security Advances, 1(1), 18-43.
- World Bank. (2025). Global Findex Database 2025 [Data set].
- World Bank. (2026). World Development Indicators [Data set].
- Yarovenko, H., Horbachova, O., Bylbas, R., & Latysh, D. (2025). Digitalization as a socio-economic challenge: Modeling the impact on the level of cybercrime considering socio-economic, technological and institutional factors. SocioEconomic Challenges, 9(2), 282-315.
- Yefimenko, A., Boronos, V., Serpeninova, Y., & Koldovskyi, A. (2025). Innovative and technological determinants of corruption reduction: How do knowledge and technology contribute to public integrity and transparency? Knowledge Economy and Lifelong Learning, 1(1), 21-34.
- Yeremenko, O. (2026). Retraining and lifelong learning as an anti-crisis tool: Preserving Ukraine’s intellectual capital in times of war. Knowledge Economy and Lifelong Learning, 2(1), 48-66.
- Zahorodnia, K., Tverdovska, Z., Yarovenko, H., & Shubenko, M. (2026). Transformational interlinkages between Ukraine’s economic and demographics potential: Implications for public governance based on the analysis of migration, public health, and citizens’ well-being shifts. Public Governance, Regulation and Law, 2(1), 80-129.
- Zambrano-Yépez, C., Guillén-Rodríguez, Y., & Henriquez-Coronel, P. (2023). Multivariate analysis of the determinants of e-government. Administratie si Management Public, 40, 132-146.


