Assessing the impact of institutional environment quality on the development of e-commerce in developed and developing countries

  • 85 Views
  • 13 Downloads

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

This study uses the new institutional economic theory and demonstrates how the quality of the institutional environment can be correlated with the development of e-commerce in different countries. The goal is to analyze the impact of international indices that assess the institutional environment on e-commerce penetration in countries with varying levels of economic development. The international indices used include the Networked Readiness Index, the E-Government Development Index, components of the Index of Economic Freedom, and indicators from The Worldwide Governance Indicators, such as control of corruption and rule of law. The level of e-commerce penetration was measured by its share in retail trade. The study analyzed developed countries with high e-commerce penetration, like the USA, the UK, Germany, South Korea, and Singapore, alongside developing countries, such as China, Turkey, Mexico, and Kazakhstan. The relationships between e-commerce penetration and international indices were identified using correlation analysis with the calculation of Spearman’s coefficient, followed by an assessment of the statistical significance of the obtained coefficients. The analysis revealed varying degrees of association between institutional quality and e-commerce penetration. Notably, the E-Government Development Index and the Networked Readiness Index showed positive correlations with e-commerce levels in all studied countries. However, the rule of law, control of corruption, and Investment Freedom indices showed varying correlations, indicating that these relationships are influenced by factors beyond economic development, such as political systems and regulatory approaches.

Acknowledgment
This study has been funded by the Science Committee of the Ministry of Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan (grant IRN AP14871419 “Formation of institutional environment of electronic commerce market in Kazakhstan, its evaluation and development mechanism”).

view full abstract hide full abstract
    • Figure A1. The share of e-commerce in retail trade in the studied countries from 2007 to 2022
    • Table 1. Main components of the e-commerce institutional environment
    • Table 2. Endogenous variables
    • Table 3. Correlation analysis using the Spearman method
    • Table 4. Correlations of time series between the share of e-commerce and international indices and their components of measuring the institutional environment
    • Conceptualization
      Aksaule Zhanbozova, Tolkyn Azatbek
    • Formal Analysis
      Aksaule Zhanbozova
    • Funding acquisition
      Aksaule Zhanbozova, Tolkyn Azatbek
    • Investigation
      Aksaule Zhanbozova, Tolkyn Azatbek, Marat Myrzakhmet
    • Methodology
      Aksaule Zhanbozova, Marat Myrzakhmet
    • Project administration
      Aksaule Zhanbozova, Marat Myrzakhmet
    • Supervision
      Aksaule Zhanbozova, Tolkyn Azatbek, Marat Myrzakhmet
    • Validation
      Aksaule Zhanbozova
    • Writing – original draft
      Aksaule Zhanbozova
    • Writing – review & editing
      Aksaule Zhanbozova, Marat Myrzakhmet
    • Data curation
      Tolkyn Azatbek
    • Resources
      Tolkyn Azatbek, Marat Myrzakhmet
    • Software
      Tolkyn Azatbek, Marat Myrzakhmet
    • Visualization
      Tolkyn Azatbek, Marat Myrzakhmet