The flypaper effect in the health area: An analysis of the municipalities of Mato Grosso State, Brazil
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/pmf.15(3).2026.07
-
Article InfoVolume 15 2026, Issue #3, pp. 93-107
- 9 Views
-
1 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Type of the article: Research Article
Abstract
The flypaper effect, explained by the theory of fiscal illusion, occurs when funds transferred from other levels of government increase spending more than funds derived from local tax revenues. This study empirically analyzes the flypaper effect on the sources of funds derived from parliamentary amendments allocated to the health sector. A quantitative and descriptive approach is used, based on a panel of data from 140 municipalities in Mato Grosso, a state located in the central-western region of Brazil, covering the period from 2014 to 2024. Employing a fixed-effects panel data regression model (estimated via OLS), the study controls for unobserved, municipality-specific characteristics that remain constant over time. The analyses confirm the occurrence of the flypaper effect in the municipalities of Mato Grosso, showing that intergovernmental transfers have a greater capacity to induce health spending than own-source revenue. The results show that the fiscal stimulus generated by external resources is significantly stronger than the increase in local government revenue. On the other hand, parliamentary amendments exert a positive impact, although marginal, acting as complementary resources that do not compromise budgetary rigidity and do not serve as the main driver of expenditure expansion during the period. The relevance of this study stems from its contribution to understanding Brazilian fiscal federalism, offering valuable empirical evidence.
Acknowledgment
The author(s) would like to thank the Dean’s Office for Research (PROPesq) at the Federal University of Mato Grosso (UFMT) for the financial support provided for the publication of this article.
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)H83, H77, H72, I18, H71
-
References35
-
Tables14
-
Figures0
-
- Table 1. Analysis of expenditure, revenue, transfers, and amendments for the state of Mato Grosso from 2014 to 2024
- Table 2. Analysis of the per capita variables for expenditures, revenue, transfers, and state amendments in the state of Mato Grosso for the period from 2014 to 2024
- Table 3. Summary of results from the fixed-effects regression of models with level variables (Log-Level)
- Table 4. M1: Classic flypaper effect test
- Table 5. M2: Budget dependency and interaction
- Table 6. M3: Costs asymmetry
- Table 7. Summary of results from the fixed-effects regression (in per capita terms)
- Table 8. M1: Confirmation of the flypaper effect and the impact of amendments
- Table 9. M2: Interaction and budgetary dependence
- Table 10. M3: Analysis of cost asymmetry
- Table 11. The log-per capita models
- Table 12. Evidence of the classic flypaper effect
- Table 13. The marginal impact of parliamentary amendments
- Table 14. Interaction and asymmetry tests
-
- Afonso, W. B. (2014). Fiscal illusion in state and local finances: A hindrance to transparency. State and Local Government Review, 46(3), 219-228.
- Albuquerque, A., & Souza, C. N. (2017). Corrupção na saúde no Brasil: Reflexão à luz da abordagem baseada nos direitos humanos [Corruption in healthcare in Brazil: A reflection in light of a human rights-based approach]. Revista Brasileira de Bioética, – Brazilian Journal of Bioethics, 13(6), 1-17. (In Portuguese).
- Almeida-Santos, P. S., Mendes, N. C. F., & Matias-Pereira, J. (2024). Impactos de ações rent-seeking sobre o orçamento público: O efeito do caso “Máfia das Ambulâncias” nos municípios mato-grossenses [Impacts of rent-seeking actions on the public budget: The effect of the „Ambulance Mafia“ case in municipalities of Mato Grosso]. Revista Brasileira de Ciência Política – Brazilian Journal of Political Science, 43, Article e275921. (In Portuguese).
- Anderson, M. C., Banker, R. D., & Janakiraman, S. N. (2003). Are selling, general, and administrative costs “sticky”? Journal of Accounting Research, 41(1), 47-63.
- Araújo, J. M., & Siqueira, R. B. (2016). Demanda por gastos públicos locais: Evidências dos efeitos de ilusão fiscal no Brasil [Demand for local public spending: Evidence of the effects of fiscal illusion in Brazil]. Estudos Econômicos (São Paulo) – Economic Studies (São Paulo), 46(1), 189-219. (In Portuguese).
- Avelino, G., & Biderman, C. (2014). A doença da corrupção: O desvio de fundos e a saúde pública nos municípios brasileiros [The disease of corruption: Misappropriation of funds and public health in Brazilian municipalities]. Anuário de Pesquisa 2013–2014 – Research Yearbook 2013–2014. FGV. (In Portuguese).
- Baptista, T. W. F., Machado, C. V., & Lima, L. D. (2012). As emendas parlamentares no orçamento federal da saúde [Parliamentary amendments to the federal health budget]. Cadernos de Saúde Pública – Public Health Notebooks, 28(12), 2267-2279. (In Portuguese).
- Berner, C. V. (2021). Relação da ilusão fiscal, do efeito flypaper e da Felicidade Interna Bruta considerando a dívida pública do Brasil [The relationship between fiscal illusion, the flypaper effect, and Gross National Happiness considering Brazil’s public debt] (Doctoral Thesis). University of Brasília. (In Portuguese).
- Caetano, C. C. R., Ávila, L. A. C., & Tavares, M. (2017). A relação entre as transferências governamentais, a arrecadação tributária própria e o índice de educação dos municípios do estado de Minas Gerais [Relation between the government transfers, own tax collection and education index of the municipalities of the state of Minas Gerais]. Revista de Administração Pública – Public Administration Review, 51, 897-916. (In Portuguese).
- Coser, I. (2008). O conceito de federalismo e a idéia de interesse no Brasil do século XIX [The concept of federalism and the notion of interest in 19th century Brazil]. Dados, 51(4), 941-981. (In Portuguese).
- Costa, R. F. R., & Castelar, L. I. de M. (2015). O impacto das transferências constitucionais sobre os gastos dos municípios Brasileiros [The impact of constitutional transfers on expenses of Brazilian municipalities]. Análise Econômica – Economic Analysis, 33(64). (In Portuguese).
- Couto, L. F., & Cardoso Junior, J. C. (2024). Planejamento, governança orçamentária e emendas parlamentares: Como conciliar racionalidade técnica, participação social e legitimidade política [Planning, budgetary governance, and parliamentary amendments: how to reconcile technical rationality, social participation, and political legitimacy]. Blog Gestão, Política e Sociedade – Blog: Management, Politics and Society. (In Portuguese).
- Cunha, I. R. (2025). Ilusão fiscal, cidadania e tributação do consumo em reforma: A (in)consciência do contribuinte antes, durante e depois (?) da Emenda Constitucional n. 132/2023 e da Lei Complementar n. 214/2025 (Reforma Tributária) [Fiscal illusion, citizenship and consumption taxation under reform: The (un)consciousness of the taxpayer before, during and after (?) Constitutional Amendment No. 132/2023 and Complementary Law No. 214/2025 (Tax Reform)]. (In Portuguese).
- Diniz, J. A., Lima, H. R., & Martins, V. G. (2017). O efeito flypaper no financiamento da educação fundamental dos municípios Paraibanos [The effect flypaper in the funding of fundamental education of municipalities in Paraiba]. Administração Pública e Gestão Social, 1(2), 95-104. (In Portuguese).
- Dollery, B. E., & Worthington, A. C. (1996). The empirical analysis of fiscal illusion. Journal of Economic Surveys, 10(3), 261-297.
- Galdino, R. H. N., & da Silva, C. G. (2025). Arrecadar e gastar ou gastar e arrecadar? Uma análise das despesas funcionais Brasileiras [Collect and spend or spend and collect? An analysis of Brazilian functional expenditures]. In 53rd National Meeting of Economics ANPEC 2025. (In Portuguese).
- Gasparini, C. E., & Miranda, R. B. (2011). Transferências, equidade e eficiência municipal no Brasil [Transfers, equity, and municipal efficiency in Brazil]. Planejamento e Políticas Públicas – Planning and Public Policies, 36, 311-349. (In Portuguese).
- Granai, F. B. (2022). Federalismo Fiscal e Desigualdades Regionais: Uma análise dos impactos do Fundo de Participação dos Municípios (FPM) sobre o desenvolvimento e a equalização fiscal [Fiscal Federalism and Regional Inequalities: An analysis of the impacts of the Municipal Participation Fund (FPM) on development and fiscal equalization] (Master’s Thesis). Universidade Estadual Paulista. (In Portuguese).
- Grossman, P. J. (1990). The impact of federal and state grants on local government spending: A test of the fiscal illusion hypothesis. Public Finance Quarterly, 18(3), 313-327.
- Leal, J. G. R. P., Lima, L. D. D., Rodrigues, F. B. S., & Silva, A. S. D. (2025). Emendas parlamentares destinadas ao Sistema Único de Saúde e a reeleição de prefeitos municipais do Brasil em 2024 [Parliamentary amendments allocated to the Unified Health System and the reelection of municipal mayors in Brazil in 2024]. Cadernos de Saúde Pública – Public Health Notebooks, 41(4), Article e00220924. (In Portuguese).
- Ministry of Finance of Brazil. (2018). O que você precisa saber sobre as transferências fiscais da união: Fundo de Participação dos Municípios FPM [What You Need To Know About Fiscal Transfers From The Union: Municipal Participation Fund FPM]. Brazil: Ministério da Fazenda, Secretaria do Tesouro Nacional. (In Portuguese).
- Ministry of Racial Equality of Brazil. (2025). Manual sobre emendas parlamentares [Manual on parliamentary amendments]. Brazil: Ministério da Igualdade Racial. (In Portuguese).
- Nojosa, G. M., & Linhares, F. C. (2018). Variabilidade do efeito flypaper e força política: Uma análise para os municípios brasileiros [The size of the flypaper effect and political strength: an analysis for Brazilian municipalities]. Pesquisa e Planejamento Econômico – Economic Research and Planning, 48(3), 137-164. (In Portuguese).
- Oates, W. E. (1988). On the nature and measurement of fiscal illusion: A survey. In G. Brennan, B. S. Grewal, & P. Groenewegen (Eds.), Taxation and fiscal federalism: Essays in honour of Russell Mathews (pp. 65-82). Australian National University Press.
- Paz, R. N., Serrano, A. L. M., & Ferreira, L. O. G. (2020). Desempenho dos municípios brasileiros: Uma análise gerencial da realidade econômica e fiscal por meio do efeito flypaper [Performance of Brazilian municipalities: A managerial analysis of the economic and fiscal reality through the flypaper effect]. Revista Universo Contábil – Accounting Universe Magazine, 16(2), 50-66. (In Portuguese).
- Piola, S. F., & Vieira, F. S. (2019). As emendas parlamentares e a alocação de recursos federais no Sistema Único de Saúde [Parliamentary amendments and the allocation of federal resources in the Unified Health System] (Discussion Paper No. 2497). Institute for Applied Economic Research (IPEA). (In Portuguese).
- Puviani, A. (1903). Teoria dell’illusione finanziaria [Theory of financial illusion]. Sandro. (In Italian).
- Rezende, F. (2007). Descentralização e transferências intergovernamentais de recursos na América Latina: Argentina, Brasil e Colômbia [Decentralization and intergovernmental resource transfers in Latin America: Argentina, Brazil, and Colombia]. Documentos y Aportes en Administración Pública y Gestión Estatal – Documents and contributions in Public Administration and State Management, (9), 55-102. (In Portuguese).
- Richartz, F., & Borgert, A. (2020). Fatores explicativos para o comportamento assimétrico dos custos das empresas listadas na B3 [Explanatory factors for the asymmetrical cost behavior of companies listed on the B3]. Revista Universo Contábil – Accounting Universe Magazine, 16(3). (In Portuguese).
- Rios, M. E., & Costa, J. S. (2005). O efeito flypaper nas transferências para os municípios portugueses [The flypaper effect on transfers to Portuguese municipalities]. Revista Portuguesa de Estudos Regionais – Portuguese Journal of Regional Studies, (8), 85-108. (In Portuguese).
- Rodden, J. (2005). Federalismo e descentralização em perspectiva comparada: Sobre significados e medidas [Comparative federalism and decentralization: On meaning and measurement]. Revista de Sociologia e Política – Journal of Sociology and Politics, (24), 9. (In Portuguese).
- Sakurai, S. N. (2013). Efeitos assimétricos das transferências governamentais sobre os gastos públicos locais: Evidências em painel para os municípios brasileiros [Asymmetrical effects of government transfers on local public spending: Panel evidence for Brazilian municipalities]. Pesquisa e Planejamento Econômico – Economic Research and Planning, 43(2), 309-322. (In Portuguese).
- Ulinski, K. G. B., Carvalho, B. G., Vieira, F. S., Rodrigues, R., & Lima, L. D. D. (2024). Efeitos das emendas parlamentares no financiamento municipal da atenção primária à saúde do Sistema Único de Saúde [Effects of parliamentary amendments on municipal financing of primary health care in the Brazilian Unified National Health System]. Cadernos de Saúde Pública – Public Health Notebooks, 40(3), Article e00007323. (In Portuguese).
- Valentin, J., & Caldeira, T. C. M. (2025). The inefficiency of IPTU collection in São Paulo municipalities. Revista Cadernos de Finanças Públicas, 25(02).
- Vieira, F. S. (2024). Financiamento federal de ações e serviços públicos de saúde por emendas parlamentares e suas implicações para a regionalização da saúde [Federal funding of public health actions and services through parliamentary amendments and its implications for the regionalization of healthcare] (Discussion Paper No. 3048). Brazil: Instituto de Pesquisa Econômica Aplicada (IPEA). (In Portuguese).


