Models of digital government, rule of law, and financial innovation: Comparative evidence across developed, developing, and transition economies, with focal cases of Ukraine, the United States, and Brazil
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/imfi.23(3).2026.29
-
Article InfoVolume 23 2026, Issue #3, pp. 414–437
- 11 Views
-
1 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Type of the article: Research Article
Abstract
Global account ownership rose from 51 to 76 percent of adults between 2011 and 2021, much of it through digital channels, yet the depth and innovativeness of national financial systems vary sharply across economies. This study quantifies how the rule of law and the model of digital government relate to two dimensions of financial-sector development, banking-sector depth and digital financial innovation, across developed, developing, and transition economies, and tests whether digital government can substitute for institutional quality. Using a panel of 183 economies over 2000–2021 (estimation window 2003–2021) and a four-wave Global Findex panel, the analysis applies two-way fixed-effects and pooled wave-fixed-effects models with country-clustered standard errors. The rule of law is positively associated with banking-sector depth, but the association is heterogeneous: it is largest and most robust in transition economies (β = 22.17, p = 0.020) and insignificant in developing economies. Digital government, by contrast, is not significantly related to banking-sector depth (p = 0.322) yet is strongly associated with digital financial innovation, where the rule of law also matters; the e-government association is strongest for digital-payment adoption (β = 51.99, p < 0.001). In these cross-country estimates, the rule-of-law × e-government interaction is negative and significant (β = −10.69, p = 0.018), and the marginal association of the rule of law declines by almost half as digital government expands, a pattern consistent with partial substitution. These findings are robust to the 2025 revision of the governance data and to extending the sample through the 2024 Findex wave.
Acknowledgments
This article was prepared based on the results of a study funded by the Ministry of Education and Science of Ukraine entitled “GovTech for Ukraine: A Digital, Secure, Transparent, and Equitable State in Times of War and Post-War Reconstruction” (registration number: 0126U000544).
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)G20, O16, O43, O33
-
References66
-
Tables16
-
Figures3
-
- Figure 1. Focal-economy dynamics: banking-sector depth (left) and account ownership (right)
- Figure 2. Heterogeneous effect of rule of law by economy type, both panels
- Figure 3. Rule of law and banking-sector depth by economy type, with focal economies
-
- Table 1. Descriptive statistics by economy type (raw depth panel, 2000–2021)
- Table 2. Descriptive statistics by economy type (digital financial innovation panel, 2011–2021)
- Table 3. Rule of law, digital government and banking-sector depth (Panel 1)
- Table 4. Rule-of-law coefficient by economy type and outlier treatment
- Table 5. Rule of law, digital government and digital financial innovation (Panel 2)
- Table 6. Robustness: alternative dependent variable and institutional indices (Panel 1)
- Table A1. Economies included in the analysis
- Table B1. Correlation matrix
- Table C1. Variance inflation factors
- Table D1. Leave-one-country-out robustness
- Table E1. Alternative measures of institutional quality (depth panel)
- Table F1. Heterogeneity of the rule-of-law effect
- Table G1. Robustness of the innovation panel under the 2025 WGI revision and the 2024 Findex wave
- Table H1. Focal cases in the innovation model, 2021 wave
- Table I1. Alternative temporal constructions of the e-government index
- Table I2. Leave-one-control-out estimates
-
- Abbasova, S., Vasylieva, T., Aliyeva, M., Gubadova, A., Ashurbayli-Huseynova, N., & Kasumova, L. (2025). Factors linking upper-middle- and high-income countries in terms of banking ecosystem digitalization: Cluster analysis. Banks and Bank Systems, 20(3), 75-90.
- Aladejebi, M. O., Ayodele, T. D., Akinyede, O. M., & Afolabi, T. S. (2026). Impact of financial reforms on digital banking adoption among rural dwellers in South-West Nigeria. Banks and Bank Systems, 21(1), 58-71.
- Asare, K. N. (2025). Digital transformation for sustainable development: Mapping the intellectual structure. Financial Markets, Institutions and Risks, 9(4), 1-15.
- Bappayo, A., Auwal, H. A., & Disa, U. (2026). Responsible journalism and sustainable development: Ethical challenges in reporting sensitive social issues. Green Transition and Sustainable Development, 2(1), 88-99.
- Bashynska, I., & Dyskina, A. (2018). The overview-analytical document of the international experience of building smart city. Business: Theory and Practice, 19, 228-241.
- Bezverkhyi, K., Parasii-Verhunenko, I., Yurchenko, O., Kazak, O., Zhytar, M., & Poddubna, N. (2024). Conceptual basis of anti-corruption audit. Financial and Credit Activity: Problems of Theory and Practice, 6(59), 77-89.
- Bondar, M., Bezverkhyi, K., Matiukha, M., Kazak, O., & Poddubna, N. (2024). Forecasting the quality assessment of integrated reporting of corporate enterprises: Empirical experience of South Africa. Financial and Credit Activity: Problems of Theory and Practice, 2(55), 269-280.
- Bozhenko, V., Boyko, A., Vondráček, M., & Karácsony, P. (2024). Shadow economy and financial stability from the perspective of finance digitalization. Journal of International Studies, 17(2), 191-205.
- Burrell, D. N. (2026). Digital trauma as a health safety and security risk: The impact of love bombing and breadcrumbing through concepts in cyberpsychology and mental public health. Safety and Security Advances, 2(1), 1-24.
- Burrell, D. N., Wansi, T., Morin, S. L., Rahim, E., Tessema, D. B., Alemu, B. A., Harris, N., & Conley, L. (2025). Harnessing behavioral economics, green promotions, and financial incentives as catalysts for sustainable practices. Green Transition and Sustainable Development, 1(1), 1-16.
- Coppedge, M., Gerring, J., Knutsen, C. H., Lindberg, S. I., Teorell, J., Altman, D., Angiolillo, F., Bernhard, M., Borella, C., Cornell, A., Fish, M. S., Fox, L., Gastaldi, L., Gjerløw, H., Glynn, A., Good God, A., Grahn, S., Hicken, A., Kinzelbach, K., ..., & Ziblatt, D. (2024). V-Dem Codebook v14. Varieties of Democracy (V-Dem) Project.
- Crowley, R. W., & Mujtaba, B. G. (2026). Human rights and the rule of law in public governance: The transformation of Black entertainment and athletic excellence in the United States. Public Governance, Regulation and Law, 2(1), 1-19.
- Davlikanova, O. (2025). Evolution of the development of the Ukrainian pattern of dual higher education. Knowledge Economy and Lifelong Learning, 1(1), 1-20.
- Del Sarto, N., & Ozili, P. K. (2025). FinTech and financial inclusion in emerging markets: A bibliometric analysis and future research agenda. International Journal of Emerging Markets, 20(13), 270-290.
- Demirgüç-Kunt, A., Klapper, L., Singer, D., & Ansar, S. (2022). The Global Findex Database 2021: Financial inclusion, digital payments, and resilience in the age of COVID-19. World Bank.
- Freedom House. (2024). Freedom in the World 2024. Washington, DC: Freedom House.
- Ghorbanian Zolbin, M., Kujala, S., Widén, G., Eriksson-Backa, K., & Huvila, I. (2025). Digital inclusion among older adults: Identifying potential solutions. Human Technology, 21(1), 51-72.
- Guseva, O. Y., Kazarova, I. O., Dumanska, I. Y., Gorodetskyy, M. A., Melnichuk, L. V., & Saienko, V. H. (2022). Personal data protection policy impact on the company development. WSEAS Transactions on Environment and Development, 18, 232-246.
- Hedau, A. (2025). Socio-economic challenges of digital banking adoption: The impact of perceived usefulness, ease of use, and self-efficacy. SocioEconomic Challenges, 9(3), 133-146.
- Hrytsenko, L., Sheliemina, N., & Latysh, D. (2026). Digital government and health system performance: Does digitalization improve the effectiveness of health expenditure? Health Economics and Management Review, 7(1), 21-40.
- Kaufmann, D., & Kraay, A. (2024). The Worldwide Governance Indicators: Methodology and 2024 update (Policy Research Working Paper No 10952). Washington, DC: World Bank.
- King, R. G., & Levine, R. (1993). Finance and growth: Schumpeter might be right. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 108(3), 717-737.
- Klochan, I., & Filipov, D. (2023). Design of assessment and forecasting of a country’s financial security in change management conditions. Smart Economy, Entrepreneurship and Security, 1(1), 31-42.
- Kuzior, A., Zakharkina, L., Kubaščikova, Z., Chentsov, V., & Lyeonov, S. (2023). Insurance market transparency research trends: Bibliometric analysis. Insurance Markets and Companies, 14(1), 136-152.
- Kyzenko, O., Sitnicki, M. W., Zahorodnia, K., Hrebeshkova, O., & Verba, V. (2026). Ethical leadership and institutional convergence in European management consulting: A cluster-based comparative analysis. Business Ethics and Leadership, 10(1), 345-366.
- La Porta, R., Lopez-de-Silanes, F., Shleifer, A., & Vishny, R. W. (1998). Law and finance. Journal of Political Economy, 106(6), 1113-1155.
- Levine, R., Lin, C., Ma, C., & Xu, Y. (2023). The legal origins of financial development: Evidence from the Shanghai concessions. The Journal of Finance, 78(6), 3423-3464.
- Lyeonov, S., Brychko, M., Korpysa, J., & Bács, Z. (2024). Cognitive mapping of the economy of trust. Economics & Sociology, 17(3), 237-266.
- Malyarets, L. M., Labunska, S., Sidak, M., Bilokonenko, H., & Onegina, V. (2025). Export–import activity and its assessment: The Ukrainian case. Administrative Sciences, 15(2), 42.
- Masyk, M., Buryk, Z., Radchenko, O., Saienko, V., & Dziurakh, Y. (2023). Criteria for governance’ institutional effectiveness and quality in the context of sustainable development tasks. International Journal for Quality Research, 17(2), 501-514.
- Meniago, C. (2025). Digital financial inclusion and economic growth: The moderating role of institutions in SADC countries. International Journal of Financial Studies, 13(1), 4.
- Mshana, S., & Postrzednik-Lotko, K. (2026). Use of modern technologies for development of sustainable tourism in Tanzania. Green Transition and Sustainable Development, 2(1), 40-64.
- Nguyen, D. T. N. (2025). Impact of e-government development, economic growth and government management efficiency on financial performance of commercial banks in ASEAN countries. Asian Journal of Economics and Banking, 9(3), 395-417.
- Noor, A. S., Alam, S., Nohong, M., & Sobarsyah, M. (2024). Investigating the impact of corporate governance and investment decisions on financial performance and firm value in insurance and banking sectors. Insurance Markets and Companies, 15(2), 122-132.
- Ntuli, F., Ntshangase, B. A., & Msosa, S. K. (2025). Innovative financial management reforms: A catalyst of good governance in the South African public sector. Financial Markets, Institutions and Risks, 9(4), 16-29.
- Pakhnenko, O., Yarovenko, H., Semenog, A., Mordan, Y., & Tarasenko, O. (2025). Uncovering patterns of digital transformation of European economies using self-organizing maps. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 23(3), 581-596.
- Prokopenko, O., Koldovskiy, A., Khalilova, M., Orazbayeva, A., & Machado, J. (2024). Development of blockchain technology in financial accounting. Computation, 12(12), 250.
- Saifi, H., & Saifi, F. (2025). Digital transformation as a socio-economic challenge: The impact on the commercial bank employees’ job performance. SocioEconomic Challenges, 9(3), 48-63.
- Sartamorn, S., Oe, H., & Yamaoka, Y. (2025). Financial stratification and digital transformation under market disruption: Evidence from Thai SMEs. Financial Markets, Institutions and Risks, 9(3), 49-63.
- Seawright, J., & Gerring, J. (2008). Case selection techniques in case study research: A menu of qualitative and quantitative options. Political Research Quarterly, 61(2), 294-308.
- Shafitranata, Alvia, L., & Azizah, R. (2026). ESG implementation and its effect on financial performance: Focusing on sustainable financial strategies of green companies in Indonesia. Environmental Economics, 17(1), 12-24.
- Shygun, M., Bezverkhyi, K., Pylypenko, O., Yurchenko, O., & Poddubna, N. (2023). Presenting financial information in digital formats as a base for analysis and audit of business activities of enterprises. Financial and Credit Activity: Problems of Theory and Practice, 6(53), 233-246.
- Sidii, F. S. (2025). Building trust and sovereignty: A holistic framework for data governance in African healthcare systems. Health Economics and Management Review, 6(3), 56-74.
- Thach, N. H., Thanh, P. T. K., Hien, N. T. T., & Hien, N. T. (2025). Integrating social customer relationship management into customer lifetime value: Empirical evidence from Vietnamese banking. Innovative Marketing, 21(3), 142-154.
- Thi Nguyen, H., Huong To, M., & Thi Nguyen, T. (2026). Digital wallet adoption and customer loyalty: The mediating role of satisfaction and moderating effects of regions in Vietnam. Innovative Marketing, 22(1), 184-204.
- To, M. H., & Tran, B. M. (2025). Environmental regulatory stringency and corporate reporting quality: Evidence from waste, emissions, water, and energy regulations in Vietnamese firms. Environmental Economics, 16(3), 67-81.
- Topazly, R., Stadniichuk, R., Liubokhynets, L., Shuprudko, N., Zhosan, H., & Plietnov, M. (2026). Institutional trust and governance effectiveness as mediators in transforming digital maturity into post-war infrastructure recovery. Business Ethics and Leadership, 10(1), 188-206.
- Tossekbayev, K., Dinits, R., & Rekun, Y. (2025). Digitalization in healthcare industry: Is there a nexus with the population’s life expectancy? Health Economics and Management Review, 6(1), 71-94.
- Tsymbal, L., & Demediuk, A. (2025). Economic security of Ukraine under war: A foreign trade perspective. Safety and Security Advances, 1(1), 63-78.
- Ugulava, G. (2026). Two faces of decline in public governance: Accountability erosion and rent-seeking. Public Governance, Regulation and Law, 2(1), 20-32.
- United Nations (UN). (2024b). World Economic Situation and Prospects 2024, Statistical Annex (Country Classification, Tables A-C). New York: United Nations. Department of Economic and Social Affairs.
- United Nations (UN). (2024a). E-Government Survey 2024: Accelerating digital transformation for sustainable development. New York: United Nations. Department of Economic and Social Affairs.
- Valaskova, K., Juracka, D., Nagy, M., & Chaudhuri, S. (2025). Digital readiness across the European Union: A multidimensional empirical assessment of structural determinants, intra-regional disparities, and strategic implications in the era of Industry 5.0. Equilibrium. Quarterly Journal of Economics and Economic Policy, 20(3), 1035-1086.
- Vasylieva, T., Vakulenko, I., & Horsch, A. (2025). The impact of electricity price shocks triggered by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine on inflation in European countries: Insights for public governance. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 23(4), 486-512.
- Waliszewski, K., Cichowicz, E., Gębski, Ł., Kliber, F., Kubiczek, J., Niedziółka, P., Solarz, M., & Warchlewska, A. (2024). Digital loans and buy now pay later from LendTech versus bank loans in the era of ‘black swans’: Complementarity in the area of consumer financing. Equilibrium. Quarterly Journal of Economics and Economic Policy, 19(1), 241-278.
- Wieczorek, A., & Postrzednik-Lotko, K. (2025). Machine learning algorithms on social media: Privacy risks, user awareness and security implications. Safety and Security Advances, 1(1), 18-43.
- World Bank. (2022). Global Financial Development Database (GFDD). Washington, DC: World Bank.
- World Bank. (2023). World Development Indicators. Washington, DC: World Bank.
- World Bank. (2025). The Worldwide Governance Indicators: Revised methodology for measuring governance using perception data. Washington, DC: World Bank.
- World Justice Project. (2024). Rule of Law Index 2024. Washington, DC: World Justice Project.
- Yarovenko, H., Bilovodska, V., Bylbas, R., Pankiv, O., Baghirzade, M., Niemi, O., & Djakons, D. (2025a). Digital readiness of European countries to combat corruption and cyber threats: Panel analysis. Business Ethics and Leadership, 9(2), 238–265.
- Yarovenko, H., Horbachova, O., Bylbas, R., & Latysh, D. (2025b). Digitalization as a socio-economic challenge: Modeling the impact on the level of cybercrime considering socio-economic, technological and institutional factors. SocioEconomic Challenges, 9(2), 282-315.
- Yefimenko, A., Boronos, V., Serpeninova, Y., & Koldovskyi, A. (2025). Innovative and technological determinants of corruption reduction: How do knowledge and technology contribute to public integrity and transparency? Knowledge Economy and Lifelong Learning, 1(1), 21-34.
- Yeremenko, O. (2026). Retraining and lifelong learning as an anti-crisis tool: Preserving Ukraine’s intellectual capital in times of war. Knowledge Economy and Lifelong Learning, 2(1), 48-66.
- Yeremenko, O., Aliyev, R., Saher, L., Shalimov, V., Matsenko, O., Hrytsenko, O., & Lyeonov, S. (2025). Post-crisis economic restructuring in the context of the EU migration crisis: The role of diverse economic models. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 23(4), 533-553.
- Zahorodnia, K., Tverdovska, Z., Yarovenko, H., & Shubenko, M. (2026). Transformational interlinkages between Ukraine’s economic and demographic potential: Implications for public governance based on the analysis of migration, public health, and citizens’ well-being shifts. Public Governance, Regulation and Law, 2(1), 80-129.


