Transparency of sustainability disclosure in agri-food value chain management: Mapping the scientific landscape

  • 107 Views
  • 22 Downloads

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Sustainability transparency in agri-food value chains is crucial for fostering accountability, enhancing consumer trust, facilitating compliance with regulatory standards, and ultimately contributing to the resilience and sustainability of food systems in the face of social, environmental, and economic challenges. This paper aims to conduct bibliometric mapping and a systematic review of the scientific landscape concerning transparency of sustainability disclosure in agri-food value chains by identifying the key transparency dimensions and relevant research gaps. An analysis of 841 Scopus-indexed publications, utilizing Scopus tools, SciVal, VOS Viewer, and Biblioshiny software, yields insights into source and author mapping from 2000 to 2022. Bibliometric analysis underlines the increase in research interests in transparency of sustainability disclosure in agri-food value chains after Sustainable Development Goals adoption and the COVID-19 pandemic, following upwards trend, especially in the UK, India, and the USA. The most influential topic clusters are supply chain, environmentally preferable purchasing, and green practices, as well as Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Internet of Things with the strongest co-occurrences between transparency (as the most recent notion in scientific landscape) and sustainability, traceability, supply chains, food supply, and blockchain. Systematic review highlights the evidence that transparency as boundary-spanning phenomenon is explored within the mono-country and chain researches, case studies and interviews methodologies from triple bottom line dimension mainly, only introducing governance criteria. Research gaps were identified regarding the role of transparency in different economic system and chains; sustainability conceptual framework used; transparency dimensions incorporation; technology-driven progress and other chain characteristics (traceability, resilience) intersection.

Acknowledgments
Inna Makarenko is gratefully acknowledging the support of MSCA4Ukraine project no. 1233713.

view full abstract hide full abstract
    • Figure 1. The dynamic of the agri-food value chains sustainability transparency publications in 2000–2022 papers
    • Figure 2. Agri-food value chains sustainability transparency publications in 2000–2022: Top countries by institutions output, papers
    • Figure 3. Top 10% of the worldwide topic cluster by prominence on agri-food value chains sustainability transparency in 2017–2022
    • Figure 4. Relevance and growth rate of critical phrases in agri-food value chains sustainability transparency, 2017–2022
    • Figure 5. Keywords co-occurrence bibliometric map on agri-food value chains sustainability transparency publications in 2000–2022 (network mode)
    • Figure 6. Keywords co-occurrence bibliometric map on agri-food value chains sustainability transparency publications in 2000–2022 (chronology mode)
    • Figure 7. Сo-authorship bibliometric map on agri-food value chains sustainability transparency publications in 2000–2022
    • Figure 8. Authors co-citation bibliometric map on agri-food value chains sustainability transparency publications in 2000–2022
    • Figure 9. Author’s production in agri-food value chains sustainability transparency in 2000–2022
    • Figure 10. Three field plots (Sankey diagram) on authors (left), countries (middle) and keywords (right) on agri-food value chains sustainability transparency publications in 2000–2022
    • Figure 11. Three field plots (Sankey diagram) on authors (left), sources (middle) and keywords (right) on agri-food value chains sustainability transparency publications in 2000 – 2022
    • Figure 12. The most frequent keywords on agri-food value chains sustainability transparency publications in 2000–2022
    • Table 1. Recent papers with literature reviews in the areas of agri-food value chains transparency of sustainability disclosure in the agri-food value chain
    • Table 2. Defining searching strings in agri-food value chains sustainability transparency
    • Table 3. Top-10 journals by output in papers of agri-food value chains sustainability transparency search strings in 2002–2022
    • Table 4. Top-10 institutions by output in agri-food value chains sustainability transparency publications, 2017–2022
    • Table 5. The top-10 topics worldwide by prominence in agri-food value chains sustainability transparency publications in 2017–2022
    • Table 6. Methodological framework and datasets used for agri-food value chains sustainability transparency
    • Table 7. Sustainability transparency dimensions in the researched sample
    • Conceptualization
      Bodo Steiner, Inna Makarenko
    • Supervision
      Bodo Steiner
    • Validation
      Bodo Steiner
    • Writing – review & editing
      Bodo Steiner, Inna Makarenko
    • Data curation
      Inna Makarenko
    • Funding acquisition
      Inna Makarenko
    • Investigation
      Inna Makarenko, Kateryna Yuhai
    • Methodology
      Inna Makarenko
    • Project administration
      Inna Makarenko
    • Software
      Inna Makarenko, Kateryna Yuhai
    • Visualization
      Inna Makarenko
    • Writing – original draft
      Inna Makarenko, Kateryna Yuhai
    • Formal Analysis
      Kateryna Yuhai
    • Resources
      Kateryna Yuhai
Related Articles

  • Research on management theory: A development review and bibliometric analysis

    Ilona SkačkauskienėORCID Researcher ID doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.21511/ppm.20(2).2022.28
    Problems and Perspectives in Management Volume 20, 2022         Issue #2         pp. 335-347 Views: 1116 Downloads: 2508 TO CITE АНОТАЦІЯ

    While the literature on management theory has been growing in recent years, there are no publications regarding the evolution and mapping of this scientific field. This study dwells on the issues related to management theories in the context of today’s research by identifying the most important lines of research, researchers, and the concentration of research. To explore the trends in the development of management theory, this study used bibliometric analysis. The search in the Web of Science database provided 5,825 documents (including articles, books, reviews, etc.). Methods of trend analysis, clusterization, and comparative analysis were used. The results show that a new direction of responsible management research is being formed – the organization’s operations and objectives must be balanced, and their implementation must be responsible. This study enriches management literature by providing new ideas related to future research tendencies. Moreover, it fleshes out the direction for developing management theory and outlines the most-cited works and authors, the research concentration in different countries, and leading journals. For scholars and practitioners, such structured data are an important source of relevant information in published papers and allows for the definition of research guidelines.

  • Mapping the literature on Gen Z purchasing behavior: A bibliometric analysis using VOSviewer

    Pingxiu LiORCID , Siti Hasnah HassanORCID doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.21511/im.19(3).2023.06
    Innovative Marketing Volume 19, 2023         Issue #3         pp. 62-73 Views: 990 Downloads: 774 TO CITE АНОТАЦІЯ

    Generation Z makes up the largest proportion of the world’s population and owns active spending power. Born in the internet information age, they have diverse values and consumer behaviors compared to other cohorts of generations. While there has been a significant increase in research on the purchasing behavior of Generation Z in recent years, there are particularly few bibliometric studies in this field. This study aims to sort out the current research status on the purchasing behavior of Generation Z, identify the evolution of purchasing behavior research of Generation Z, determine key research hotspots, and explore future research directions and priority suggestions by analyzing the current literature. The bibliometric analysis is based on the citation information of 638 literature items about Generation Z purchasing behavior in the Scopus database. The results sort out the knowledge structure of the purchasing behavior domain of Generation Z and draw a visual map of the network. Four popular research themes are identified based on keyword co-occurrence analysis, namely the influencing factors of Generation Z consumption behavior, the comparative study with other generations of consumers, the analysis from the perspective of human demography, and the study of sustainable consumption behavior. Studies on Generation Z consumers’ spending habits from 2001 to 2022 may be divided into three stages related to the growth process of Generation Z. Future research should focus on the influence of social media on the purchasing behavior of Generation Z and the sustainability of their consumption patterns.

  • Assessing the degree of development of dynamic capabilities theory: A systematic literature review

    Arcadio Gonzalez-SamaniegoORCID , Marco A. Valenzo-JimenezORCID Researcher ID, Jaime Apolinar Martinez-ArroyoORCID Researcher ID, Salvador Antelmo Casanova ValenciaORCID doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.21511/ppm.21(3).2023.34
    Problems and Perspectives in Management Volume 21, 2023         Issue #3         pp. 418-434 Views: 954 Downloads: 407 TO CITE АНОТАЦІЯ

    Dynamic capabilities theory has become one of the most widely accepted theories of business strategy. The study aims to determine the degree of development of the dynamic capabilities theory. A meta-analysis was carried out through a bibliometric analysis and a systematic literature review. Documents published in Scopus and Web of Science between 1997–2023 were analyzed using VOSviewer software. 49 documents met the analysis requirements, with a maximum of 11 published in 2022. Keyword co-occurrences were also analyzed. 222 were found, and 26 were selected with at least two co-occurrences. The documents were grouped into six clusters by these keywords and analyzed to determine the degree of development of the theory. The results have shown popularity among researchers in different science branches, indicating a high degree of development. However, the study noted a lack of theoretical consistency in elaborating constructs for measuring variables in empirical investigations. As a result, this leads to a lack of consistency and generalization of the results. Hence, the theory is not considered fully developed in terms of lack of internal coherence, falsifiability, and predictability. Tools for the empirical measurement of variables need to be theoretically and empirically validated to ensure their application in different contexts. The confrontation of results from validated measurement tools in diverse environments will contribute to developing dynamic capabilities theory.

    Acknowledgment
    We appreciate the support granted through the Postdoctoral Stays program by CONAHCYT.

Download Preview
Close
Problems and Perspectives in Management
Problems and Perspectives in Management