The dark side of the circular economy: The value uncaptured in bioeconomy business models
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/ppm.21(4).2023.39
-
Article InfoVolume 21 2023, Issue #4, pp. 516-531
- Cited by
- 442 Views
-
99 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
The bioeconomy, grounded in the shift from fossils to bio-based resources, plays an important role in the Net Zero 2050 scenario. However, even if rooted in circular thinking, bioeconomy business models are not free from environmental, social, and economic concerns. This paper deals with the causes of the unsustainability of business models in the biofuels sector, embracing an unconventional approach that focuses on the uncaptured value. The value uncaptured is the negative aspect of value, and it consists of creating too much or not enough value during the product lifecycle. Value uncaptured can threaten the sustainability of circular business models, which is why it constitutes the ‘dark side’ of circular strategies. Starting from a gap in the existing literature and supported by theoretical background, this study aims to suggest a theoretical framework to identify the causes of the negative value in the biofuel sector. The paper uses a qualitative tool, namely a case study analysis. The findings reveal that circular business models can suffer from value uncaptured, which can take the form of value absence, value destroyed, value surplus, and value missed. Identifying these forms of value can transform them into opportunities for value creation. These results enrich the research on the circular economy with a new and unconventional approach. The elaborated theoretical framework can become a qualitative tool to identify what causes companies’ circular business models to underperform.
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)Q01, M21, Q20
-
References71
-
Tables3
-
Figures1
-
- Figure 1. Theoretical framework for the identification of value uncaptured
-
- Table 1. Beginning of life of biofuel: Transformation of biomass
- Table 2. Middle of life of biofuel: Distribution and use
- Table 3. End of life of biofuel: Externalities
-
- Antikainen, M., & Valkokari, K. (2016). A framework for sustainable circular business model innovation. Technology Innovation Management Review, 6(7), 5-12.
- Baškarada, S. (2014). Qualitative case study guidelines. The Qualitative Report, 19(40), 1-18.
- Beames A., Claassen, G. D. H., & Akkerman, R. (2021). Logistics in the circular economy: Challenges and opportunities. In J. Rezaei (Ed.), Strategic Decision Making for Sustainable Management of Industrial Networks (pp. 1-14). Springer.
- Bengtsson, M. (2016). How to plan and perform a qualitative study using content analysis. Nursing Plus Open, 2, 8-14.
- Bocken, N., Strupeit, L., Whalen, K., & Nußholz, J. (2019). A review and evaluation of circular business model innovation tools. Sustainability, 11(8), 2210.
- Bocken, N.M., Rana, P., & Short, S.W. (2015). Value mapping for sustainable business thinking. Journal of Industrial and Production Engineering, 32(1), 67-81.
- Boons, F., & Lüdeke-Freund, F. (2013). Business models for sustainable innovation: State-of-the-art and steps towards a research agenda. Journal of Cleaner Production, 45, 9-19.
- Broccardo, L., Vola, P., Zicari, A., & Alshibani, S. M. (2023). Contingency-based analysis of the drivers and obstacles to a successful sustainable business model: Seeking the uncaptured value. Technological Forecasting & Social Change, 191, 122513.
- Bröring, S., & Vanacker, A. (2022). Designing business models for the bioeconomy: What are the major challenges? EFB Bioeconomy Journal, 2, 100032.
- Bröring, S., Laibach, N., & Wustmans, M. (2020). Innovation types in the bioeconomy. Journal of Cleaner Production, 266, 121939.
- Cao, H., & Folan, P. (2012). Product life cycle: The evolution of a paradigm and literature review from 1950–2009. Production Planning & Control, 23(8), 641-662.
- Cavanagh, S. (1997). Content analysis: Concepts, methods and applications. Nurse Researcher, 4(3), 5-16.
- Cerantola, N. (2019). Ecologing: Circular economy.
- Cheng, J. J., & Timilsina, G. R. (2011). Status and barriers of advanced biofuel technologies: A review. Renewable Energy, 36(12), 3541-3549.
- Circle Economy. (2022). The Circularity Gap Report 2022. Amsterdam: Circle Economy.
- Comitato Tecnico Italiano (CTI). (n.d.). Produzione e utilizzo dei biocombustibili liquidi derivati da oli vegetali [Production and use of liquid biofuels derived from vegetable oils]. (In Italian).
- Daou, A., Mallat, C., Chammas, G., Cerantola, N., Kayed, S., & Aoun Saliba, N. (2020). The Ecocanvas as a business model canvas for a circular economy. Journal of Cleaner Production, 258(2), 120938.
- Dhiman, S., & Mukherjee, G. (2021). Present scenario and future scope of food waste to biofuel production. Journal of Food Process Engineering, 44(2), e13594.
- Donner, M., Verniquet, A., Broeze, J., Kayser, K., & de Vries, H. (2021). Critical success and risk factors for circular business models valorising agricultural waste and by-products. Resources Conservation and Recycling, 165, 105236.
- Eggemann, L., Escobar, N., Peters, R., Burauel, P., & Stolten D. (2020). Life cycle assessment of a small-scale methanol production system: A power-to-fuel strategy for biogas plants. Journal of Cleaner Production, 271, 122476.
- Elkington, J. (1994). Towards the sustainable corporation: Win-win-win business strategies for sustainable development. California Management Review, 36(2), 90-100.
- Ellen MacArthur Foundation. (2015). Toward the circular economy: Economic and business rationale for an accelerated transition.
- European Commission. (2012). Innovating for sustainable growth: A bioeconomy for Europe. Publications Office.
- European Commission. (2018). A sustainable Bioeconomy for Europe: Strengthening the connection between economy, society and the environment – Updated bioeconomy strategy. Publications Office.
- Fehrenbach, H., Bürck, S., & Wehrle, A. (2023). The carbon and food opportunity costs of biofuels in the EU27 plus the UK. Institut für Energie- und Umweltforschung Heidelberg.
- Flick, U. (2009). An introduction to qualitative research (4th ed.). London: SAGE Publications Ltd.
- Geissdoerfer, M., Bocken, N. M., & Hultink, E. J. (2016). Design thinking to enhance the sustainable business modelling process – A workshop based on a value mapping process. Journal of Cleaner Production, 135, 1218-1232.
- Geissdoerfer, M., Pieroni, M. P. P., Pigosso, D. C. A., & Soufani, K. (2020). Circular business models: A review. Journal of Cleaner Production, 277, 123741.
- Gennari, F. (2022a). Sustainable business model innovation: From value uncaptured to value opportunities. Symphonya. Emerging Issues in Management, 2, 27-46.
- Gennari, F. (2022b). The transition towards a circular economy. A framework for SMEs. Journal of Management and Governance, 27, 1423-1457.
- Gennari, F., & Cassano, R. (2020). Circular economy and strategic risk. Symphonya. Emerging Issues in Management, 1, 136-148.
- Girotra, K., & Netessine, S. (2014). Four paths to business model innovation. Harvard Business Review.
- Groom, M. J., Gray, E. M., & Townsend, P. A. (2008). Biofuels and biodiversity: Principles for creating better policies for biofuel production. Conservation Biology, 22(3), 602-609.
- Hennink, M., Hutter, I., & Bailey, A. (2020). Qualitative research methods. Thousand Oaks: SAGE Publications Limited.
- Hyde, P. (2008). Working with stories: Diverse tales of organizational life. Qualitative Research in Organizations and Management, 3(2), 147-158.
- International Energy Agency. (n.d.). Bioenergy.
- Jones, M. J., & Shoemaker, P. A. (1994). Accounting narratives: A review of empirical studies of content and readability. Journal of Accounting Literature, 13, 142-184.
- Jun, H., Kiritsis, D., & Xirouchakis, P. (2007). Research issues on closed-loop PLM. Computers in Industry, 58(8-9), 855-868.
- Karmee, S. K. (2016). Liquid biofuels from food waste: Current trends, prospect and limitation. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 53, 945-953.
- Keßler, L., Matlin, S. A., & Kümmerer, K. (2021). The contribution of material circularity to sustainability – Recycling and reuse of textiles. Current Opinion in Green and Sustainable Chemistry, 32, 100535.
- Kirchherr, J., Reike, D., & Hekkert, M. (2017). Conceptualizing the circular economy: An analysis of 114 definitions. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 127, 221-232.
- Koilo, V. (2021). Developing new business models: Logic of network value or cross-industry approach. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 19(2), 291-307.
- Konietzko, J., Bocken, N., & Hultink, E. J. (2020). A tool to analyze, ideate and develop circular innovation ecosystems. Sustainability, 12(1), 417.
- Kuzior, A., Vakulenko, I., Kolosok, S., Saher, L., & Lyeonov, S. (2023). Managing the EU energy crisis and greenhouse gas emissions: Seasonal ARIMA forecast. Problems and Perspectives in Management 21(2), 383-399.
- Leggett, K., Mykkänen, J., Repo, P., & Lammi, M. (2023). Evolving markets in the circular economy: A network analysis of exemplary company cases. In S. G. Scholtz, R. J. Howlett, & R. Setchi (Eds.), Sustainable Design and Manufacturing (pp. 98-109). Springer.
- Lewandowski, M. (2016). Designing the business models for circular economy – Towards the conceptual framework. Sustainability, 8(1), 43.
- Mah, A. (2021). Future-proofing capitalism: The paradox of the circular economy for plastics. Global Environmental Politics, 21(2), 121-142.
- Maxwell, J. A. (2005). Qualitative research design: An interactive approach (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks: Sage.
- Méndez-León, E., Reyes-Carrillo, T., & Díaz-Pichardo, R. (2022). Towards a holistic framework for sustainable value analysis in business models: A tool for sustainable development. Business Strategy and the Environment, 31(1), 15-31.
- Mendoza, J. M. F., Sharmina, M., Gallego-Schmid, A., Heyes, G., & Azapagic, A. (2017). Integrating backcasting and eco-design for the circular economy: The BECE framework. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 21(3), 526-544.
- Ncube, A., Mtetwa, S., Bukhari, M., Fiorentino, G., & Passaro, R. (2023). Circular economy and green chemistry: The need for radical innovative approaches in the design for new products. Energies, 16(4), 1752.
- Nußholz, J. L. K. (2018). A circular business model mapping tool for creating value from prolonged product lifetime and closed material loops. Journal of Cleaner Production, 197, 185-194.
- OECD. (2020). Labour market consequences of a transition to a circular economy: A review paper – Environment working paper N°162 (ENV/WKP(2020)9).
- Osterwalder, A., & Pigneur, Y. (2010). Business model generation – A handbook for visionaries, game changers and challengers. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons.
- Osterwalder, A., Pigneur, Y., Bernarda, G., & Smith, A. (2014). Value proposition design. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons.
- Rathore, D., Nizami, A., Singh, A., & Pant, D. (2016). Key issues in estimating energy and greenhouse gas savings of biofuels: Challenges and perspectives. Biofuel Research Journal, 3(2), 380-393.
- Reim, W., Sjödin, D., Parida, V., Rova, U., & Christakopoulos, P. (2017). Bioeconomy based business models for the forest sector – A systematic literature review. In Bioeconomy Challenges (pp. 775-780).
- Salvador, R., Barros, M.V., da Luz, L.M., Piekarski, C.M., & de Francisco, A.C. (2020). Circular business models: Current aspects that influence implementation and unaddressed subjects. Journal of Cleaner Production, 250, 119555.
- Salvador, R., Puglieri, F. N., Halog, A., de Andrade, F.G., Piekarski, C.M., & de Francisco, A. C. (2021). Key aspects for designing business models for a circular bioeconomy. Journal of Cleaner Production, 278, 124341.
- Salvioni, D. M., Bosetti, L., & Fornasari, T. (2022). Implementing and monitoring circular business models: An analysis of Italian SMEs. Sustainability, 14(1), 270.
- Santa-Maria, T., Vermeulen, W. J. V., & Baumgartner, R. J. (2021). Framing and assessing the emergent field of business model innovation for the circular economy: A combined literature review and multiple case study approach. Sustainable Production and Consumption, 26, 872-891.
- Sartirana, E., Vita, M., La Groia, A., & Vico, M. (2021). Terre rare, l’elephant in the room della transizione ecologica: Come emanciparsi dalle fonti di energia fossile rischiando una rinnovata dipendenza da materia prime critiche [Rare earths, the elephant in the room of the ecological transition: How to emancipate ourselves from fossil energy sources, risking a renewed dependence on critical raw materials]. Leggiscomodo. (In Italian).
- Sofaer, S. (1999). Qualitative methods: What are they and why use them? Health Services Research, 34(5), 1101-1118.
- Szilagyi, A., Cioca, L. I., Bacali, L, Lakatos, E. S., & Birgovan, A. L. (2022). Consumers in the circular economy: A path analysis of the underlying factors of purchasing behaviour. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 19(18), 11333.
- Testa F., Iovino R., & Iraldo F. (2020). The circular economy and consumer behaviour: The mediating role of information seeking in buying circular packaging. Business Strategy and the Environment, 29(8), 3435-3448.
- Thornley, P., & Gilbert, P. (2013). Biofuels: Balancing risks and rewards. Interface Focus, 3(1), 20120040.
- Timilsina, G. R., Marvel, S., & Shrestha, A. (2011). Oil price, biofuels and food supply. Energy Policy, 39(12), 8098-8105.
- Tura, N., Hanski, J., Ahola, T., Ståhle, M., Piiparinen, S., & Valkokari, P. (2019). Unlocking circular business: A framework of barriers and drivers. Journal of Cleaner Production, 212(1), 90-98.
- Wagner, R., & Kabalska, A. (2023). Between involvement and profit: Value (un-)captured by a born-social start-up. Journal of Social Entrepreneurship.
- Yang, M., Evans, S., Vladimirova, D., & Rana, P. (2017). Value uncaptured perspective for sustainable business model innovation. Journal of Cleaner Production, 140(3), 1794-1804.
- Zuccaro, G. (2023). Why we should support biofuel production. Fuels, 4(2), 261-263.