A tactical asset allocation strategy that exploits variations in VIX

  • 1804 Views
  • 863 Downloads

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Buy and hold strategies make staying disciplined difficult for investors, especially given the variability of returns for different asset classes/strategies during divergent market conditions. Market timing strategies, on the other hand, present significant theoretical benefits, but in reality these benefits are difficult to obtain. Tactical asset allocation, where limited deviations from the strategic allocation are allowed permits the portfolio manager to take advantage of market conditions fits between these two extremes. The authors correlate daily returns for each of eighteen separate asset classes typically used in diversified institutional portfolios and daily closing values of the VIX (the ticker symbol for the Chicago Board Options Exchange Volatility Index). This information is used to select those classes whose returns are most responsive to the level of the VIX. Portfolio allocations for eight selected asset classes are revised depending on the level of the VIX at the daily close of the market. The portfolio is rebalanced on the business day following the day the VIX hits the trigger value. The VIX tactical allocation overlay yields an increase in return over the buy and hold portfolio of approximately 38 basis points. The authors conclude that the tactical asset allocation strategy based on the level of VIX provides a higher return than the neutral buy and hold allocation with a higher Sharpe ratio and lower volatility.

view full abstract hide full abstract
    • Table 1. Asset class returns vs the VIX
    • Table 2. Asset allocation vs the VIX
    • Table 3. Annual return statistics
    • Table 4. Difference in returns and standard deviations, VIX minus neutral
    • Table 5. Difference in Sharpe Ratio, VIX minus Neutral
    • Bauer, Richard J., and Dahlquist, Julie R. (2001). Market Timing and Roulette Wheels. Association for Investment Management and Research, 57(1) (January/February), 28-40.
    • Bollerslev, T. (1986). Generalized Autoregressive Conditional Heteroskedasticity. Journal of Econometrics, 31, 307-327.
    • Boscaljon, B., Filbeck, Greg, and Xin, Zhao. (2011). Market Timing Using the VIX for Style Rotation. Financial Services Review, 20, 35-44.
    • Bouchey, Paul, Nemtchinov, Vassiilii, Paulsen, Alex, and Stein, David M. (2012). Volatility Harvesting: Why Does Diversifying and Rebalancing Create Portfolio Growth? The Journal of Wealth Management, 15(2), 26-35.
    • Brenner, M., and Galai, D. (1989). New Financial Instruments for Hedging Changes in Volatility. Financial Analysts Journal, 45(4), (July/August), 16-22.
    • Brinson, G. P., Hood, L. R., and Beebower, G. L. (1986). Determinants of Portfolio Performance. Financial Analyst Journal, 42(4) (July/August), 39-44.
    • Cipollini, A. P. L., and Manzini, A. (2007). Can the VIX Signal Market’s Direction? An Asymmetric Dynamic Strategy. UBS Research Paper.
    • Chicago Board of Options (2009). The CBOE Volatility Index – VIX, Chicago Board Of Options Exchange, Inc.
    • Chua, Jess H., Richard S. Woodward, and Eric C. To. (1987). Potential Gains from Stock Market Timing in Canada. Financial Analysts Journal, 43(5), (September/October), 50-56.
    • Copeland, Maggie M., and Copeland, Thomas E. (1999). Market Timing: Style and Size Rotation. Financial Analysts Journal, 55(2), 73-81.
    • Droms, William G. (1989). Market Timing as an Investment Policy. Financial Analysts Journal, 45(1) (January/February), 73-77.
    • Engle, Robert F. (1982). Autoregressive Conditional Heteroscedasticity with Estimates of the Variance of United Kingdom Inflation. Econometrica, 50(4) (July), 987-1007.
    • Fleming, Jeff, Kirby, Chris, and Ostdiek, Barbara (2001). The Economic Value of Volatility Timing. The Journal of Finance, 56(1), 329-352.
    • French, Kenneth, Schwert, G. William, and Stambaugh, Roger (1987). Expected Stock Returns and Volatility. Journal of Financial Economics, 19(1), 3-30.
    • Jeffrey, Robert H. (1984). The Folly of Stock Market Timing. Harvard Business Review (July-August), 102-110.
    • Kester, George W. (1990). Market Timing with Small versusLarge-Firm Stocks: Potential Gains and Required PredictiveAbility. Financial Analysts Journal, 46(5) (September/October), 63-69.
    • Munenzon, Mikhail (2010). 20 Years of VIX: Fear, Greed and Implications for Traditional Asset Classes. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1583504.
    • Philips, Thomas K., Rogers, Greg T., and Capaldi, Robert E. (1996). Tactical Asset Allocation: 1977-1994. Journal of Portfolio Management, 23(1), 57-64.
    • Sharpe, William F. (1975). Likely Gains from Market Timing. Financial Analysts Journal, 31(2) (March/April), 60-69.
    • Shilling, A. Gary. (1992). Market Timing: Better than a Buy-and-Hold Strategy. Financial Analysts Journal, 48(2) (March/April), 46-50.
    • Thomas K. Philips, Greg T. Rogers, and Robert E. Capaldi. (1996). Tactical Asset Allocation: 1977-1994 (Digest Summary). Journal of Portfolio Management, 23(1), 57-64.
    • Whaley, Robert E. (1993). Derivatives on Market Volatility: Hedging Tools Long Overdue. Journal of Derivatives, 1, 71-84.
    • Whaley, Robert E. (YEAR). Understanding the VIX, 2009. Journal of Portfolio Management, 35, 98-105.
Related Articles

  • A conservative discontinuous target volatility strategy

    Simone Cirelli , Sebastiano VitaliORCID , Sergio Ortobelli LozzaORCID , Vittorio Moriggia doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.21511/imfi.14(2-1).2017.03
    Investment Management and Financial Innovations Volume 14, 2017         Issue #2 (cont. 1)         pp. 176-190 Views: 1591 Downloads: 652 TO CITE АНОТАЦІЯ

    The asset management sector is constantly looking for a reliable investment strategy, which is able to keep its promises. One of the most used approaches is the target volatility strategy that combines a risky asset with a risk-free trying to maintain the portfolio volatility constant over time. Several analyses highlight that such target is fulfilled on average, but in periods of crisis, the portfolio still suffers market’s turmoils. In this paper, the authors introduce an innovative target volatility strategy: the discontinuous target volatility. Such approach turns out to be more conservative in high volatility periods. Moreover, the authors compare the adoption of the VIX Index as a risk measure instead of the classical standard deviation and show whether the former is better than the latter. In the last section, the authors also extend the analysis to remove the risk-free assumption and to include the correlation structure between two risky assets. Empirical results on a wide time span show the capability of the new proposed strategy to enhance the portfolio performance in terms of standard measures and according to stochastic dominance theory.

  • On the non-linear relationship between VIX and realized SP500 volatility

    Manuel G. Russon , Ahmad F. Vakil doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.21511/imfi.14(2-1).2017.05
    Investment Management and Financial Innovations Volume 14, 2017         Issue #2 (cont. 1)         pp. 200-206 Views: 1180 Downloads: 841 TO CITE АНОТАЦІЯ

    VIX, a ticker symbol for Volatility Index, measures the implied annual volatility of at-the-money SP500 Index Options. Conventional wisdom presumes VIX to measure the magnitude (positive or negative) of possible movements in future equity prices, with movements being a positive function of VIX. This research investigates the nature of the relationship between VIX and SP500 volatility, and answers the question as to whether that relationship is linear or nonlinear. Based on this research paper, the authors conclude that the realized SP500 volatility is nonlinear, and grows with the level of VIX at an increasing rate. The nonlinearity relationship between VIX and SP500 has enormous implications for investment management and hedging in the financial markets.

Download Preview
Close
Investment Management and Financial Innovations
Investment Management and Financial Innovations