Toward a novel Sustainability Transparency Index for improved governance in agri-food value chains: A comparative study of Finnish and Ukrainian companies
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/afc.05(1).2024.06
-
Article InfoVolume 5 2024, Issue #1, pp. 68-81
- 104 Views
-
16 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
The paper addresses ESG-based disclosure and transparency measurement in the context of a comparative analysis of Finnish and Ukrainian agri-food businesses based on the Sustainability Transparency Index (STI) and Sustainable Development Goals (SDG). Based on the normalization method, SDG-related text mining, and qualitative text analytics, the sustainability information of the largest agri-food companies was traced. Among GRI, ISSB, and ESRS disclosure standards, only GRI 13 has clearly established SDG alignment with most material stakeholders’ requests. The results of the study give a snapshot of sustainability transparency in the agri-food business in 2023, where the indices of Finnish companies are higher than those of Ukrainian ones, with clear SDG 12, waste and water management priority compared to SDG 2 and sustainable agriculture in Ukraine. Regulatory recommendations based on a comparative analysis of sustainability disclosure in both countries include better alignment with EU (Finnish) benchmarks, reporting and assurance practices for Ukrainian companies, and the incorporation of recent EU sustainability disclosure approaches for Finnish companies.
Acknowledgment
Inna Makarenko gratefully acknowledges the support of the Academy of Finland (Decision 353888).
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)E01, Q01, Q10, M40, M41
-
References41
-
Tables6
-
Figures6
-
- Figure 1. Most relevant SDGs in Ukrainian company sustainability reporting (in order of priority, the percentage of co-occurrences corresponding to each goal)
- Figure 2. Most relevant SDGs in Finnish company sustainability reporting (in order of priority, the percentage of co-occurrences corresponding to each goal)
- Figure 3. SDG targets detected in Ukrainian company sustainability reporting (percentage of keywords relevant to each goal)
- Figure 4. SDG targets detected in Finnish company sustainability reporting (percentage of keywords relevant to each target)
- Figure 5. Mind map on Ukrainian company sustainability reporting
- Figure 6. Mind map on Finnish company sustainability repo
-
- Table 1. STI calculations for Ukrainian sample companies in 2023 (extract)
- Table 2. STI calculations for Finnish sample companies in 2023 (extract)
- Table 3. SDG prioritization in Ukrainian company sustainability reporting
- Table 4. SDG prioritization in Finnish companies’ sustainability reporting
- Table 5. Topical clusters in Ukrainian company sustainability reporting
- Table 6. Topical clusters in Finnish companies’ sustainability reporting
-
- Agnew, H., Klasa, A., & Mundy S. (2022). How ESG investing came to a reckoning. Financial Times.
- Altarawneh, M. S. (2023). The impact of environmental disclosure on value relevance: Moderating role of environmental performance. Environmental Economics, 14(2), 69-86.
- Bai, G. V., Frank, D., & Prabhu, K. S. (2024). Does ESG disclosure enhance firm performance during COVID-19? Evidence from Nifty 500 firms. Investment Management and Financial Innovations, 21(3), 74-83.
- Elalfy, A., Weber, O., & Geobey, S. (2021) The Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): a rising tide lifts all boats? Global reporting implications in a post SDGs world, Journal of Applied Accounting Research, 22(3), 557-575.
- European Commission (EC). (2024). JRC SDG Mapper.
- Fernandez-Feijoo, B., Romero, S., & Ruiz, S. (2014). Effect of stakeholders’ pressure on transparency of sustainability reports within the GRI framework. Journal of Business Ethics, 122(1), 53-63.
- Gardner, T. A., Benzie, M., Börner, J., Dawkins, E., Fick, S., Garrett, R., Godar, J., Grimard, A., Lake, S., Larsen, R. K., Mardas, N., McDermott, C. L., Meyfroidt, P., Osbeck, M., Persson, M., Sembres, T., Suavet, C., Strassburg, B., Trevisan, A., ..., & Wolvekamp, P. (2019). Transparency and sustainability in global commodity supply chains. World Development, 121, 163-177.
- Gereffi, G., & Lee, J. (2016). Economic and social upgrading in global value chains and industrial clusters: Why governance matters. Journal of Business Ethics, 133(1), 25-38.
- Gereffi, G., Lim, H. C., & Lee, J. (2021). Trade policies, firm strategies, and adaptive reconfigurations of global value chains. Journal of International Business Policy, 4(4), 506-522.
- Global Reporting Initiative (GRI). (2024). Sector standard for agriculture, aquaculture, and fishing. Global Reporting Initiative
- Goswami, K., Islam, M. K. S., & Evers, W. (2023). A case study on the blended reporting phenomenon: A comparative analysis of voluntary reporting frameworks and standards – GRI, IR, SASB, and CDP. The International Journal of Sustainability Policy and Practice, 19(2), 35-64.
- Kostetckaia, M., & Hametner, M. (2022). How sustainable development goals interlinkages influence European Union countries’ progress towards the 2030 Agenda. Sustainable Development, 30(5), 916-926.
- Kovalov, B. (2024). Relationship between sustainable development indicators and SMEs’ development indicators: Evidence from the EU countries. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 22(2), 71-92.
- Largest Companies. (2024). Suurimmat yritykset liikevaihdon mukaan ilman tytäryhtiöitä [The largest companies by turnover without subsidiaries] (In Finnish).
- Latifundist. (2024). Top 100 largest agricultural companies.
- Makarenko, I., Makarenko, S., & Rubanov, P. (2023). Greenwashing Detection and Impact on Responsible Business and Investment: Case of Ukrainian Companies (Agriculture Leaders). In Strielkowski, W. (Ed.), Leadership, Entrepreneurship and Sustainable Development Post COVID-19. NILBEC 2022. Springer Proceedings in Business and Economics. Cham: Springer.
- Makarenko, I., Plastun, A., Kozmenko, S., Kozmenko, O., & Rudychenko, A. (2022a). Corporate Transparency, Sustainable Development and SDG 2 and 12 in Agriculture: The Case of Ukraine. AGRIS on-line Papers in Economics and Informatics, 14(3), 57-70.
- Makarenko, I., Plastun, A., MazancovаJ., Juhaszova, Z., & Brin, P. (2022b). Transparency of agriculture companies: rationale of responsible investment for better decision making under sustainability. Agricultural and Resource Economics: International Scientific E-Journal, 8(2), 50-66.
- Mol, A. P. (2015). Transparency and value chain sustainability. Journal of Cleaner Production, 107, 154-161.
- Morningstar. (2022). Global Sustainable Fund Flows: Q1 2022 in Review.
- Papoutsi, A., & Sodhi, M. S. (2020). Does disclosure in sustainability reports indicate actual sustainability performance? Journal of Cleaner Production, 260, 121049.
- Plastun, A., Makarenko, I., Khomutenko, L., Osetrova, O., & Shcherbakov, P. (2020). SDGs and ESG disclosure regulation: Is there an impact? Evidence from top-50 world economies. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 18(2), 231-245.
- Political Watch. (2024). Scanner 2030.
- Pucker, K. P. (2021). Overselling sustainability reporting. Harvard Business Review, 99(3), 134-143.
- Rajic, S., Đorđević, V., Tomasevic, I., & Djekic, I. (2022). The role of food systems in achieving the sustainable development goals: Environmental perspective. Business Strategy and the Environment, 31(3), 988-1001.
- SDR. (2022). Finland.
- Shevchenko, H., Petrushenko, M., Burkynskyi, B., & Khumarova, N. (2021). SDGs and the ability to manage change within the European Green Deal: The case of Ukraine. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 19(1), 53-67.
- Soni, T. K. (2023). Demystifying the relationship between ESG and SDG performance: Study of emerging economies. Investment Management and Financial Innovations, 20(3), 1-12.
- Steiner, B. E. (2017). A phenomenon-driven approach to the study of value creation and organizational design issues in agri-business value chains. Food Economy/Economia Agro-Alimentare, 19(1), 89-118.
- Steiner, B., & M. Brandhoff (2021). An analysis of configurations of relationship quality dimensions to explain sources of behavioral outcomes in globalized manufacturing. European Journal of Marketing, 55(13), 1-40.
- Sukhonos, V., Makarenko, I., Serpeninova, Y., & Qasimova, G. (2018). Classification and prioritization of stakeholders’ information requests according to Sustainable Development Goals: Case of cross-sector partnership in the Ukrainian food production industry. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 16(4), 126-140.
- Thammaraksa, C., Gebara, C. H., Hauschild, M. Z., Pontoppidan, C. A., & Laurent, A. (2024). Business Reporting of Sustainable Development Goals: Global Trends and Implications. Business Strategy and the Environment, 33(6), 5445-5462.
- Timperley, J. (2021). The broken $100-billion promise of climate finance – and how to fix it. Nature, 598, 400-402.
- UNCTAD. (2020). International SDGs investment flows to developing economies down by one third due to COVID-19. SDGs investment Trends Monitor.
- United Nations (UN). (2016) Report of the Inter-Agency and Expert Group on Sustainable Development Goal Indicators (E/CN.3/2016/2/Rev.1, Annex IV). (pp. 39-62).
- United Nations (UN). (2021). Food Systems Summit x SDGs.
- United Nations (UN). (2022). Lack of Grain Exports Driving Global Hunger to Famine Levels, as War in Ukraine Continues, Speakers Warn Security Council. Security Council Meeting notes.
- Vorontsova, A., Rieznyk, O., Treus, A., Oleksich, Z., & Ovcharova, N. (2022). Do environmental protection investments contribute to environmentally-oriented SDGs? Environmental Economics, 13(1), 141-154.
- WEF. (2022a). The war in Ukraine is pushing countries short on food to famine.
- WEF. (2022b). Ukraine war is leading to a global food and energy crisis.
- Wiguna, M., Indarti, S., Thamrin, & Andreas. (2023). Determinants of sustainable development: The role of CSR disclosure. Problems and Perspectives in Management, 21(2), 210-220.