Do COVID-19 containment policies influence equity market returns? Evidence from the ASEAN-5

  • 14 Views
  • 2 Downloads

Creative Commons License DMCA.com Protection Status
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Type of the article: Research Article

Abstract
This study investigates the short- and long-term effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on ASEAN-5 stock markets, Malaysia, Indonesia, Singapore, Thailand, and the Philippines, emphasizing differences between cyclical and non-cyclical sectors. It aims to evaluate how effectively these emerging markets are handling pandemic-related information in a context of extreme uncertainty. The study employs the event study and Buy-and-Hold Abnormal Return (BHAR) methodologies for the year 2020. The finding indicates asymmetric market responses across the ASEAN-5. In the short term, Malaysia (–0.56%), Indonesia (–8.35%), and Singapore (–0.42%) experienced significant declines in cumulative abnormal returns (CAR) (–1,1). Long-term results for 1 to 6 months show gradual recovery in Malaysia (6.97%), Indonesia (5.13%), and Singapore (7.65%). Sectoral analysis reveals that Malaysia’s financial sector (FIN) posted CAR of three days (−1.68%) (p < 0.01) and five days (−3.18%) (p < 0.10). Next comes Indonesia’s cyclical sector, the transportation sector’s three-day (−9.40%) and five-day (21.91%) CAR (both p < 0.01). For Singapore’s mineral resources (MR), the two-day (−1.74%) and seven-day (−2.91%) CARs are statistically significant at least at 10%. In the Philippines, the sectoral reaction was −0.94% to −2.44% over two and seven days for the financial (FIN) sector; in Thailand, the financial (FIN) and utilities (UTI) sectors had CAR of −2.26% over three days and −4.58% over three days, respectively. These findings support the semi-strong form of market efficiency, indicating temporary deviations in behavior. The paper provides a comprehensive review of market efficiency in systemic crises and new insights into sector resilience and policy-driven economic recovery in developing countries.

Acknowledgment
This paper used Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) such as ChatGPT and Co-Pilot to improve the language and the core idea.

view full abstract hide full abstract
    • Table 1. CAR results among ASEAN-5 countries
    • Table 2. Long-run abnormal return (buy-and-hold return)
    • Table A1. CAR assessment results in different sectors among ASEAN-5 countries
    • Table A2. BHAR results in different sectors among ASEAN-5 countries
    • Conceptualization
      Norhamiza Ishak, Eva Nur, Chia Yee Ee
    • Data curation
      Norhamiza Ishak, Eva Nur, Chia Yee Ee
    • Formal Analysis
      Norhamiza Ishak
    • Methodology
      Norhamiza Ishak, Chia Yee Ee
    • Writing – original draft
      Norhamiza Ishak
    • Investigation
      Eva Nur
    • Resources
      Eva Nur, Chia Yee Ee
    • Writing – review & editing
      Eva Nur, Chia Yee Ee