Indirect taxation on VAT consumption. A possible study of alternative tax rate models in Portugal
-
DOIhttp://dx.doi.org/10.21511/imfi.20(4).2023.14
-
Article InfoVolume 20 2023, Issue #4, pp. 156-170
- Cited by
- 378 Views
-
170 Downloads
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
The adoption of a single VAT rate system in the EU is a complex and controversial issue, since the current model includes several differentiated rates and is intended to reflect sectoral needs and ensure greater fairness in the taxation of consumption. This study aims to analyse which of the general consumption tax models (differentiated rates or a single rate) is more efficient in terms of revenue collection. The study uses official statistics available on the official website of the Tax and Customs Authority for the period 1996–2022. VAT revenue is measured by applying the formula of the EU’s common VAT model with the necessary adaptations to the flat rate model. Quantitative methods are applied to verify which of the tax models is more efficient in terms of collection. For this purpose, two scenarios were defined (17% and 21%). The results suggest that the estimated revenues for the proposed flat rate models are higher than the amounts actually collected through the differentiated rates. They also suggest that the 21% flat rate is preferable to the 17% rate, although the latter has the capacity to maintain current revenue levels and increase the amount collected compared to the current system. The conclusions suggest that the single VAT rate model is technically more preferable and notably more efficient than the current common consumption tax model adopted by the European Union. The study concludes that the refusal to adopt the single-rate model is not due to technical reasons but to political ones.
- Keywords
-
JEL Classification (Paper profile tab)E62, H21, H22, H25
-
References46
-
Tables1
-
Figures2
-
- Figure 1. VAT revenue with differentiated rates and estimated VAT revenues with a single rate of 17% and 21% (in M€)
- Figure 2. Laffer curve for VAT revenue with differentiated rates and for estimated VAT revenues with single rates of 17% and 21% (in M€)
-
- Table 1. VAT revenue with differentiated rates and estimated VAT revenues with single rates of 17% and 21%
-
- Adhikari, B., & Alm, J. (2017). Evaluating the economic effects of flat tax reforms using synthetic control methods (Working Paper 01/2017).
- Alavuotunki, K., Haapanen, M., & Pirttilä, J. (2016). The effects of the value-added tax on revenue and inequality. The Journal of Development Studies, 55(4), 490-508.
- Albino, F. (1999). Imposto Único. In M. Cintra (Ed.), Imposto Único sobre Transações (Prós e Contras) [Single Transaction Tax (Pros and Cons)] (pp. 32-34). São Paulo: Câmara Brasileira do Livro. (In Portuguese).
- Bahl, R., & Wallace. S. (2007). From income tax to consumption tax? the case of Jamaica. FinanzArchiv/Public Finance Analysis, 63(3), 396-414.
- Baldini, M., & Rizzo, L. (2021). Flat tax: European experiences and Italian proposals. Hacienda Pública Española / Review of Public Economics, 238(3), 137-162.
- Basham, P., & Mitchell, D. (2008). Lessons from abroad: flat tax in practice. In J. Clemens (Ed.), The impact and cost of taxation in Canada: the case for flat tax reform (pp. 103-144). The Fraser Institute, Canada.
- Becker, A. (1974). Property tax reform: an analysis of a proposal for Milwaukee. Proceedings of the Annual Conference on Taxation Held under the Auspices of the National Tax Association-Tax Institute of America, 67(1974), 92-129.
- Bickley, J. (2003). Value added tax: concepts, policy issues, and OECD experiences. Nova Publishers.
- Braz, C., & Cunha, J. (2009). Os efeitos redistributivos do IVA em Portugal [The redistributive effects of VAT in Portugal]. Boletim Económico, 2009, 79-94. (In Portuguese).
- Burman, L., & Slemrod, J. (2020). Taxes in America: what everyone needs to know. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Carvalho, A., Lukic, M., Sachsida, A., Oliveira, C., & Lozardo, E. (2018). Uma reforma dual e modelar da tributação sobre o consumo no Brasil [A dual and modelled reform of consumption taxation in Brazil]. Rio de Janeiro: Instituto de Pesquisa Econômica Apicada. (In Portuguese).
- Catarino, J., & Soares, R. (2019). Restructuring the European VAT tax system: advantages and disadvantages of the adoption of a single-rate model – a study based on the Portuguese case. European Journal of Government and Economics, 8(2), 145-160.
- Catarino, J., Soares, R., & Correia, P. (2017). Ensaio sobre a reestruturação do sistema de tributação indireta: análise socioeconómica sobre as vantagens e inconvenientes da adoção de um modelo de taxa única em Portugal [Essay about the restructuring of indirect tax system: socio-economic analysis about the advantages and disadvantages of adopting a single rate in Portugal]. Trabajo y Sociedad: Sociología del trabajo-Estudios culturales – Narrativas sociológicas y literárias, 28, 109-124. (In Portuguese).
- Cintra, M. (1991). Por uma revolução tributária. In M. Cintra (Ed.), Imposto único sobre transações (prós e contras) [Single Transaction Tax (Pros and Cons)] (pp. 7-11). São Paulo: Câmara Brasileira do Livro. (In Portuguese).
- Cintra, M. (1994). Tributação no Brasil e o imposto único [Taxation in Brazil and the single tax]. McGraw-Hill. (In Portuguese).
- Cintra, M. (2003). A Verdade sobre o imposto único, eficiência, comodismo, sonegação, obsolescência, interesses corporativos, cumulatividade fatos e mitos da reforma tributária no Brasil [The truth about the single tax, efficiency, convenience, evasion, obsolescence, corporate interests, cumulativeness - facts and myths about tax reform in Brazil]. LCTE Editora. (In Portuguese).
- Cintra, M. (2009). Bank transactions: pathway to the single tax ideal. A modern tax technology; the Brazilian experience with a bank transactions tax (1993-2007). Fundação Getulio Vargas.
- Clemens, J., Emes, J., & Scott, R. (2003). The flat tax – a model for reform of personal and business taxes. In H. Grubel (Ed.), Tax reform in Canada: our path to greater prosperity (pp. 53-76). The Fraser Institute, Canada.
- Comissão do IVA. (1984). O impacto do IVA na economia portuguesa [The impact of VAT on the Portuguese economy]. Imprensa Nacional-Casa da Moeda. (In Portuguese).
- Correia. I. (2007). Efeito sobre a equidade de um aumento do imposto sobre o valor acrescentado [Equity effect of an increase in value added tax]. Boletim Económico, 2007, 91-100. (In Portuguese).
- Gale, W. (1999). Flat tax. In J. Cordes, R. Ebel, and J. Gravelle (Eds), The Encyclopedia of Taxation and Tax Policy (pp. 155-158). Washington, D.C.: Urban Institute Press.
- Gravelle, J. (2003). Across-the-board tax cuts: economic issues. In J. Larson, (Ed.), Tax cuts: issues and analyses (pp. 31-46). New York: Nova Science.
- Grecu, A. (2004). Flat tax – the British case. Adam Smith Institute.
- Griffiths, S., & Leach, R. (2018). British politics. Bloomsbury Publishing.
- Ivanova, A., Keen, M., & Klemm, A. (2005). The Russian flat tax reform (IMF Working Paper, WP/05/16).
- James, K. (2015). The rise of the value-added tax. Cambridge University Press.
- Laura-Liana, S., & Carmen, A. (2009). The flat tax effects: theoretical and empirical evidence in Western and Eastern European countries. Annals of Faculty of Economics, 3(1), 343-348.
- Mankiw, N., Weinzierl, M., & Yagan, D. (2009). Optimal taxation in theory and practice. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 23(4), 147-174.
- Mgammal, M., Al-Matari, E., & Alruwaili, T. (2023). Value-added-tax rate increases: A comparative study using difference-in-difference with an ARIMA modeling approach. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 121, 1-17.
- Mihaescu, F., & Voinea, L. (2009). The impact of the flat tax reform on inequality: the case of Romania. The wiiw Balkan Observatory, 81, 1-23.
- Mohs, J. (2019). Evaluating flat tax theory: a conceptual framework. Journal of Business & Economic Policy, 6(4), 13-16.
- Nabais, J. (2010). Reflexões sobre quem paga a conta do estado social [Reflections on who foots the bill for the welfare state]. Revista da Faculdade de Direito da Universidade do Porto, 7, 51-83. (In Portuguese).
- Núcleo do IVA. (1986). Imposto sobre o Valor Acrescentado (IVA): princípios gerais [Value Added Tax (VAT): general principles]. Rei dos Livros. (In Portuguese).
- Palma, C. (2011). O orçamento do estado para 2012: a proposta de orçamento do estado para 2012 e as taxas do IVA [The state budget for 2012: the draft state budget for 2012 and VAT rates]. Revista de Finanças Públicas e Direito Fiscal, 4(3), 77-98. (In Portuguese).
- Palma, C. (2012). A recente comunicação da comissão sobre o futuro do IVA [The commission’s recent communication on the future of VAT]. Revista TOC, 12(144), 48-55. (In Portuguese).
- Paulus, A., & Peichl, A. (2008). Effects of flat tax reforms in Europe on inequality and poverty. IZA DP, 3721, 1-34.
- Popescu, M., Militaru, E., Stanila, L., Vasilesu, M., & Cristescu, A. (2019). Flat-Rate versus progressive taxation? An impact evaluation study for the case of Romania. Sustainability, 11(22), 1-16.
- Rot, R., & Heuty, A. (2012). Fiscal space: policy options for financing human development. Taylor & Francis.
- Shrivastava, M., & Gupta, S. (2004). Economics of value added tax (VAT). APH Publishing.
- Siqueira, R. (2001). IVA uniforme com renda básica: uma proposta de reforma da política tributária e social no Brasil [Uniform VAT with basic income: a proposal for tax and social policy reform in Brazil]. Instituto Brasileiro de Economia. (In Portuguese).
- Soares, R. (2014). O IVA no paradigma da eficiência e simplicidade: uma proposta para a implementação de uma taxa única de IVA [VAT in the paradigm of efficiency and simplicity: a proposal for the implementation of a single VAT rate] (Master’s Thesis). Lisbon: University of Lisbon, Higher Institute of Social and Political Sciences. (In Portuguese).
- Soares, R. (2021). A tributação indireta sobre o consumo em sede de IVA. Um estudo de modelos alternativos de taxa de imposto [Indirect taxation of consumption under VAT. A study of alternative tax rate models] (Doctoral Thesis). Lisbon: University of Lisbon, Higher Institute of Social and Political Sciences. (In Portuguese).
- Teller, L. (2011). The flat tax: an analysis of America’s most controversial tax reform idea.
- Tomás, J. (2012). Uma taxa única para o IVA em Portugal? [A single VAT rate in Portugal?]. Revista de Finanças Públicas e Direito Fiscal, 3(2), 19-29. (In Portuguese).
- Vasques, S. (2023). Cadernos IVA 2017. Almedina.
- Wynands, S. (2018). The future of tax in New Zealand. The Treasury, 2018, 1-9.